Prayer Focus
Click here to watch THE HOPE on-line!
Movie Review


MPAA Rating: PG-13 for war action violence and some sexual content

Reviewed by: Sheri McMurray

Add to your list?
View your list
Moviemaking Quality:

Primary Audience:
Adults, Teens
Action, Adventure, Drama, War
2 hr. 19 min.
Year of Release:
USA Release:
September 22, 2006 (wide)
Copyright, Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer (MGM)
Copyright, Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer (MGM)
Copyright, Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer (MGM)
Copyright, Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer (MGM)
Copyright, Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer (MGM)
Copyright, Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer (MGM)
Copyright, Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer (MGM)
Copyright, Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer (MGM)
Copyright, Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer (MGM)
Copyright, Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer (MGM)
Copyright, Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer (MGM)
Relevant Issues
Copyright, Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer (MGM)


What is the Christian perspective on war? Answer

Racism, Racial Issues and Christianity
Get biblical answers to racial hot-topics. Where did the races come from? How did skin color come about? Why is it important to have a biblical foundation for such issues?

What are the consequences of racial prejudice and false beliefs about the origin of races? Answer

Why does God allow innocent people to suffer? Answer

What about the issue of suffering? Doesn’t this prove that there is no God and that we are on our own? Answer

Does God feel our pain? Answer

Paradise or Pain? Why is the world the way it is?
Why is the world the way it is? If God is all-knowing, all-powerful, and loving, would He really create a world like this? (filled with oppression, suffering, death and cruelty) Answer
Is Jesus Christ the answer to your questions?
Discover the good news that Jesus Christ offers
Click here to watch THE HOPE on-line!
The Bible is the world’s best selling book of all time. But for most, it remains a mystery. Now, discover for yourself the overwhelming message of HOPE that God brings to man—presented chronologically from the foundation of the world to our own time. Watch it on-line, full-length motion picture.
Featuring: James Franco, Jean Reno, David Ellison, Martin Henderson, Jennifer Decker
Director: Tony Bill (“Chicago Hope,” “Untamed Heart”)
Producer: Dean Devlin, Marc Frydman
Distributor: Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer (MGM)

A tribute to the American “Escadrille Lafayette”

“To keep alive in the hearts of men the spirit which inspired the members of the ‘Escadrille Lafayette,’ all Americans, to volunteer for the universal cause of Liberty under the Flag of France.”
—Inscription on The Lafayette Escadrille Memorial

We have forgotten that for 225 years and more, two great nations—the United States and France—have stood together in the long fight for individual freedom, equality, and intrinsic worth.

In these days of a near anti-patriotic thrust in the American culture, with no respect for (and a bent on insulting) the Presidential office and it’s foreign policies, it is refreshing to see a film which represents our collective hearts as a faithful nation, tied to honor freedom for all—at any cost—which is a truth that existed in the not so distant past.

From the United States, many brave men—volunteers all—made their way to France early on to stand with that nation against Imperial Germany in the Great War of 1914-1918, known to history as World War 1.

By 1917, the Allied powers of France, England, Italy, and others were nearly overwhelmed as they fought against the German military, whom at that time had been extremely well trained. Some altruistic young Americans disagreed with the German malice and the oppression of that war. They volunteered to fight alongside their counterparts in France; some in the infantry, some in the Ambulance Corps.

A handful of others had a different idea: they decided to learn how to fly! The first of them—a squadron of only 38—became known as the Lafayette Escadrille. “Flyboys” is their story.

Based on actual events, the names of the aviators in this film are not listed in any historical record, although the Lafayette Escadrille Flying Corps was a bona fide reality. It’s existence is backed by books, bios, cartoons, an exhibit in the New England Air Museum, and numerous Web sites. The most commanding of all, is the Lafayette Escadrille Memorial—erected in a park outside of Paris and midway to Versailles.

A young Texan, in trouble with the local law and floundering to hang onto an over-mortgaged family ranch, sees a newsreel chronicling the adventures of young aviators in France. At a small train station in rural Nebraska, a young naive boy promises to make his family proud. In New York, a spoiled upstart embarks on a trans-Atlantic passage that will change his family’s view of him forever. Meanwhile, in France, a black expatriate boxer, vows to repay his debt to his adopted racially-tolerant country. Together, these American boys arrive at an aerodrome in France, eager to be involved. What they didn’t realize was that they were about to embark on a great, romantic adventure, becoming the world’s first combat pilots.

Blaine Rawlings (ever endearing, “Spiderman” alum James Franco) leaves for France, not to do something worthy, but to do something different with his dull, declining life. As he passes through Paris, the sights of the dead and wounded from the war is a wake up call that things might be a little different than the gallant newsreels back home in Texas depicted.

Along with the other American volunteers, Blaine arrives in Luxeuil, later moved closer to the front at Bar-le-Duc, unable to speak the language and faced with the even greater challenge of learning to operate a device that was only invented 10 years before the war began—the airplane.

Commanding them is the firm, yet fair, French Capitaine Thenault (Jean Reno, whom you may remember from “The Pink Panther” and “The Da Vinci Code” and, I might add, is the only character who sports the name of an actual Lafayette Escadrille Captain). After listening to these fresh young American boys make light “fun” of their situation, Captain Thenault lets them know that their mission for France and in this platoon is serious. He addresses them in English, “Along with the English, French and others, you Americans are the first and only to join. You have joined the fight to preserve freedom. The life expectancy is anywhere between three to six weeks.”

They quickly realize the vital and grave extent of their situation. At this point, France has been in the war for three years and has lost millions of men in battle. They have been fighting against a much superior German military. It is time for the tables to turn.

Reed Cassidy (from “Bride and Prejudice,” Martin Henderson) is their training “Ace” who is professional, confident and emotionally distant. Cassidy commands respect, while living with these boys in their barracks set up in a donated French chateau. He commands respect while in the air and through the platoon mascot—a lion, whom he commands just as much respect from, named “Whisky”—Cassidy keeps his authority unquestioned.

Blaine and the othzer young Americans, nicknamed “flyboys,” are put under vigorous training not anticipated when they enlisted. Long hours in the air, and long nights away from home and family begin to wear on William Jensen (Philip Winchester) who dreams of his young fiancé back home in Nebraska, and rich kid Briggs Lowry (“Boston Legal”’s Tyler Labine), who is hesitant to share his quarters with a black Eugene Skinner (Abdul Salis) because his brief connection to blacks has been as his servants, only. Add to this already tense scenario that Briggs is convinced Eddie Beagle (David Ellison) is a German spy, even though he is an American from Wisconsin, and the undercurrent of anxiety mounts.

Ultimately, through steady and constant training, they are exposed to each other’s personal lives, fears, strengths as well as weaknesses, eventually becoming as close as brothers and breaking down any and all ethnic and social barriers. Soon, transformed from boys into men, they become a squad willing to sacrifice their very lives for one another and for this war—the Great War for freedom.

When Blaine crashes his plane in the French countryside and falls in love with Lucienne (a sweetly believable Jennifer Decker) who finds him and nurses him back to health, the story complicates. Through his love for Lucienne and her brave little family, Blaine learns firsthand the heart-wrenching costs of war as it has radically affected their lives. Lucienne’s brother and wife were killed by a German bombing while innocently sitting in their home, leaving behind their three young children for Lucienne to raise, she being but a teenager herself.

Dennis Gorden, advisor on this film, has done well in keeping the production’s early 20th century view on track. Attention to detail in the clothing, grounds and even the canvas-covered and balsa wood planes are near perfect. It’s hard to imagine that these are merely replicas of the Indian Head (a sign of bravery) insignia’d bi-planes flown by the original Lafayette Escadrilles themselves.

The story by Blake T. Evans and screenplay from Phil Spears, David S. Ward and Blake T. Evans, even though it tries to tell too much with too many characters for the time allotted for this movie, still stays together and keeps us interested in each and every one. Tony Bill’s work as director is promising, as he transformed himself from TV producer to film director.

“Flyboys” is not an epic saga, nor is it a B-movie. It is a fine representation of comradery, dedication to a basic moral cause, heroics, love and sacrifice. The reference to the seriousness of war is repeated as these young boys learn that one must think carefully before entering into this type of situation, but once there not to back out, instead devote oneself to the cause, to those whose life you are defending, and follow through.

I cannot help but think of one minor, though important character named Lyle Porter played by Michael Jibson. He seems to be the only guy there who came to France knowing what he was getting himself into. He is a Christian with a dedicated Christian motive. He knows he is fighting for freedom and the right for every person on the planet to live peacefully. As he sings “Onward Christian Soldiers,” he fights to the death with a bravery that is not coming from reliance on his own abilities. I took notice that he was getting his fighting power from his faith in God. Porter knew His God, and he knew where he was going when he was shot down in battle.

PG-13 is right on the mark. Although there are very brief references to sex, no one is shown having it. One pilot is shown with his pants down. There is a whore house in the French countryside, and members from the squadron are shown visiting the ladies there, but again no sex scene is ever shown on camera. Real, true love is shown between the characters of Lucienne and Blaine. Their love is shown as pure, and only one kiss is shared between them onscreen, and is shown as sweet and gentle.

There is lots of war violence, bombing, explosions, shooting guns from the planes, blood, burning planes with men still in them, and shooting from the trenches. There are at least two scenes where a person is shown falling out of a plane, and as is with CGI effects, looks very realistic. One fighter is shot in the head, and another character’s hand is cut off, but the act is not shown on camera.

There is drinking, and drinking shown as a sign of male virility, as was (and still is) a part of Army life. I am not condoning it, I am just stating fact. The act of taking a “shot of bourbon” as a sign of how many “kills” a pilot has made, may seem callus to some. Also, each fighter pilot has “stars” or “X”s painted on the side of his plane for how many German fighters he has shot down. This also is a harsh reality and was a real part of war time heroism for fighter pilots then and even on into WWII. One character lifts his glass and shouts, “Drink up, you’re still alive!” He also makes his toast to “virginity.”

Through it all, I didn’t count any profanity or reference to The Lord’s name taken in vain. Instead, faith in God was emphasized. The men said a prayer for “courage” and used phrases like “may God be with you.” There was more than one scene where a priest blessed the men and their planes as they went into or came back from battle. A pilot is shown praying, while yet another makes the sign of the Cross. It is clear these men wanted to do something worthy with their lives. They were taught and believed that “the man, and not the machine is what mattered.” Some mottos adhered to were: Don’t grieve over the things you cannot change, but instead stand for human justice and the honorable things of God. Every man is your brother, no matter what color his skin or his background.

War is not always against God’s will. There are times when it is our responsibility to God’s will which institutes war as a means to a Holy end to prejudice and genocide. Let us be reminded that in the book of Judges God designates Judah as the tribe to begin fulfilling His command to be an instrument of justice against the wicked Canaanites. God blesses Judah’s obedience with victory. As in all wars, theirs is the victory who go with God.

[What is the Christian perspective on war? Answer]

By August 1917, the La Fayette Escadrille had won four Legions of Honor, seven Medailles Militaire and thirty one citations, each citation accompanied by a Croix de Guerre.

I would recommend this MGM movie to families, but caution parents that “Flyboys” has very realistic CGI effects centered around fighting/war scenes. Children under 13, and those who may not be prepared for scenes of war so authentically depicted, may want to wait for a later time, after careful discussions about war and how God’s will fits into the picture. Indeed, the dog fights were thrilling! The CGI effects are well worth the price of a ticket!

“Flyboys” could even turn into a history lesson, sparking your teen’s (or tween’s) interest into further research about WWI, the notion of “dog fights,” and other facts of this era, including the fighting Escadrilles, such as:

  • There really were large felines within the squadron barracks: Two lion cubs, named “Whiskey” and “Soda,” were made squadron mascots.

  • On February 8, 1918 the squadron was reorganized into the US Army (as hinted at in the finale of “Flyboys”). Most of the veteran members were set to work training newly arriving American pilots.

  • It can also be noted that the world’s first black military aviator, Eugene Bullard, flew with the Lafayette Flying Corps.

  • The character in “Flyboys” known as Reed Cassidy bears a definite resemblance to real-life Lafayette Escadrille “Ace” Thomas Gantz Cassady from Freedom, Indiana, who was awarded numerous medals and merits.

  • There actually is The Lafayette Escadrille Memorial outside of Paris, France.

  • The monument is composed of a central Arch of Triumph, one-half-size of the Arch of Triumph in Paris. Upon the stone are inscribed the names of the dead American pilots of the Escadrille La Fayette and the Lafayette Flying Corps during the first World War 1914-1918. Also, inscribed thereon are the French towns and provinces where these pilots were involved in aerial fights with the German forces. The inscriptions are in French on one side and in English on the other side of the monument. Under the monument is a sanctuary crypt including 68 sarcophagi.

  • The famed Lafayette Escadrille (Squadron), remain the only all-American squadron of volunteers flying under the French flag in World War I. The squadron included thirty-eight members at final tally. In all, 269 American aviators served France as volunteers in what came to be designated officially by the French government as the Lafayette Flying Corps, including the Lafayette Escadrille.

  • Kiffin Rockwell (one of the real-life first members of the Corps) wrote in partial explanation of his taking up France’s fight, “I pay my debt for Lafayette and Rochambeau.” If we in America should stand in mortal peril; and bereft of aid, would we not take heart if some young Frenchman were to arrive in our camp proclaiming, “I pay my part for Pershing and Eisenhower.”?

    Kiffin Rockwell was slain during a valiant fight with an enemy plane, on September 23rd, 1916.

  • French-American relations have been strained for more than a year [since the War on Terrorism began], given that the government in Paris flatly opposed the U.S. incursion into Iraq. [“FLYBOYS”] provides a broader historical perspective on relations that go back more than two centuries.

Ref:——Lafayette Flying Corps Memorial Foundation

Violence: Heavy / Profanity: None / Sex/Nudity: Mild

Viewer Comments
Comments below:
Positive—This is a great film. It’s not Oscar material, but it’s very good, language is almost spotless, and there’s very little sex involved. I recommend it to history buffs like myself.
My Ratings: Average / 3
—Shannon, age 25
Positive—Great movie for the family! Good storyline and excellent acting. The computer animation was amazing. “Flyboys” was clean, with very little swearing, which was surprising. We thoroughly enjoyed this film.
My Ratings: Good / 5
—Chad, age 20
Positive—This is definitely a war movie in the “old school” style. The plot revolves around the standard mix of characters (cowboy, rich kid, minority, religious guy, etc.) who must learn to accept and trust each other during difficult circumstances. The battle sequences (which weren’t as many as I was expecting) are quite exciting and well done. The computer animation did not get in the way, as it sometimes can. There is some graphic violence, as people get shot up in battle, but nothing really gory. While the main character is put into situations where he can question his actions, that is, his killing of other human beings, and the overall morality of war, there’s still a feeling of “rah rah” jingoism throughout and that may be why a lot of the movie critics gave “Flyboys” such low marks. The characters start the movie in idealism, and while they become more realistic by the end of the movie, they do not become fatally disillusioned or bitter and resentful, as seems to be required in a lot of movies these days.

As for the moral quality, I heard one profane remark (taking the Lord’s name in vain), around the middle of the movie, when someone was complaining about the guns jamming. There’s also a scene where two of the characters accidentally wind up in a brothel, but since the girls are wearing early 20th century underwear, they are better covered than many girls you see at the mall today! I found this movie very entertaining and heartily recommend it.
My Ratings: Good / 4
—Philip, age 33
Positive—Yes, it was predictable, but it made my heart race and my daughter cry. It was also nice to see the French being treated fairly and as courageous, moral and worthy allies. Though it had the classic good German and bad German, and some even clapped when the evil “boche” (black plane and all) got his just deserts, I bought it all. This was a throw back to the old war movies where there were good guys and bad guys and it worked. There are wars that have to be fought—the Iraq war may not be one of them, but WWI was. Finally, though I appreciate the references to Christianity in the movie, it was treated as somewhat of an aberration rather than as central as I know it was during that period and is still today (at least, as the saying goes, in the foxhole). I would have liked to see some struggle with the moral issue of whether a “Christian soldier” is a contradiction in terms, but the movie has already been criticized as too long (though I don’t agree). I also liked that the hero was very happy when he learned his love interest was not a prostitute but a “good” girl.
My Ratings: Better than Average / 4
—Dan, age 47

[Editor’s note: Read—What is the Christian perspective on war? Answer]

Positive—Just returned from seeing the movie. It was a small audience (all men), some who had met original members of the squadron. The movie overall is good, though some of the special effects leave a bit to be desired. There is very little swearing, and no sexual scenes within the movie. It does portray the actual aerial combat experiences of WWI pilots and the dangers/rewards of such a life. You get to know the pilots and what drives them, but also get a glimpse of their personal lives.

The planes do look real, though in some of the aerial scenes especially in close ups, other planes do not have that “real” look. The combat sequences are very good. I do not know if the smoke (tracer) rounds are authentic, but they do allow one to follow the bullet track. It does show how difficult it was to aim at a moving object. It also shows some of the grief that men have when they lose their brothers in combat, and how many of them dealt with that grief. Overall, a decent movie. It will probably end up in my collection when it comes out in DVD
My Ratings: Better than Average / 4
—Dave, age 56
Positive—Exceptional film! Portrays the bravery, camaraderie and dedication of real life young men who volunteered to fight beside the French against German tyranny in WWI. I appreciate that James Franco's character shows respect and gentleman-like behavior toward the young woman he meets in France (initially he mistakes her for a prostitute because of a crazy situation he falls into… won’t give away more details). War/history buffs will dig it, and there’s enough romance in the plot to keep the wife from nodding off! Very positive values shown throughout:
- Sacrificial acts for friends.
- Determination in spite of difficulties.
- Courage in the face of danger.
- Male affirmation (from older generation French commanders).
There’s enough comic relief too to keep it from being too heavy being a war flick. The special effects are very convincing… you’ll feel like you’re in the air with those boys! Bravo!
My Ratings: Good / 4
—Scott Anderson, age 41
Positive—I loved this movie! The brotherly love and concern shown by these former strangers was remarkable. The story was good, but the fight scenes and visual effects were intense and outstanding. It will have you clinching on the arms of your chairs. There was minimal cursing and 1 occasion of God’s name being taken in vain. The love between the main character and Lucianne was done in a very tasteful way. This was a really good movie and it was like Top Gun, but it was a lot more intense(considering these guys fly in open cock-pit airplanes). Go see this movie, but if your kids scare in intense scenes, caution them.
My Ratings: Better than Average / 5
—Lori, age 42
Positive—“Flyboys” tends to follow the mold of “Pearl Harbor,” love story/military flick. Is this a ploy for young men to drag along their female companion, like a young gal would rope her man into sitting through “The Lake House”? The effects, the imagery and the overall storyline takes us back in time to a part of history that one doesn’t remember or may have never heard about. The film has all the right ingredients with “factual” events, suspense and love interest. A mixture of seasoned actors and unknowns round out a workable, believable cast. PG-13 rating keeps the film acceptable for most teenagers, like my 14 year old son, with some language and depicted war scenes.
My Ratings: Better than Average / 4
—Phil Ward, age 41
Positive—I found this film to be a good depiction of history for anyone who is a war buff. I would remind the readers of this forum that if you are looking for a film that has excellent morals and absolutely no sculpturally objectionable content, you should not be going to a movie theater or viewing anything coming out of Hollywood as you are guaranteed to be disappointed.
My Ratings: Good / 2
—Cliff, age 40
Negative—I walked out of the film when it was half over. I did so when they used God’s name in vain. …
My Ratings: Extremely Offensive / 2
—Gerald Stevens, age 63
Negative—Not suitable for any Christian. It used the Lord’s name in vain. We walked out.
My Ratings: Extremely Offensive / 1
—Melody, age 29
Comments from young people
Positive—“Flyboys” is incredible! It is one of the best movies of the year. The sexual content was surprisingly tame—there is some brief immodesty, but in all seriousness, a trip to Wal-mart will yield worse immodesty (that’s not a joke). There were only a few swear words, including one GD. I was pleasantly surprised in the main character’s always doing the just and honorable thing.

There was also a Christian character who they spent some time on, which I was thankful for. The only other negative was some drinking, and even that was tame. The acting was great, the story superb (although a bit predictable), and the effects incredible. And, it doesn’t have your typical “happy ever after” ending. This is an incredible movie that is worth more than one viewing and I recommend it.
My Ratings: Better than Average / 4
—Geno, age 16
Positive—I just got back from seeing this movie, and I thought it was absolutely great! It had great messages. It had great character development and the special effects were awesome. It was very clean except for a few mild swear words. I highly recommend this film!
My Ratings: Good / 5
—Anthony, age 11
Positive—Of all the theater movies I’ve gone to, and of all the war movies I’ve seen, this has to be one of the better ones. “Flyboys” is a relatively clean war movie, so I don’t have much to warn you about…

Language: There isn’t extensive language, and in fact, I don’t think I caught a single bad word throughout the whole thing. Maybe one D.
Gore/Violence: There isn’t extensive gore, but yet, there is some blood, as it is war, and that sort of thing happens. Yes, people die, but expect that from a war movie.
Movie-making Quality: The action and storyline were very intriguing overall and had my father, brothers, and myself on the edge of our seats.

Things Christians need to look out for: Be warned that there is a certain pilot in particular who does not seem to believe in God or anything else. He “honors” his friends by drinking for them after they die. I’m glad the hero disagrees and does what’s right. So a little bit to watch there.

Things Christians can agree with: I must say, the Christian pilot in this movie is portrayed well (at least I think so), and though he may be made fun of a few times, he did what was right, read his Bible, and even sings “Onward Christian Soldiers” as he battles. I found this very thrilling. Finally a movie with good morals. If there is a theater still playing it, go check it out.
My Ratings: Excellent! / 4½
—Stephan, age 15
Positive—This movie was fantastic! There was very little swear words and no sex. The movie is pretty predictable but is still enjoyable. I usually don’t like war movies but this movie was excellent. I recommend this for anyone who likes a good action movie.
My Ratings: Better than Average / 5
—Josh, age 16
Positive—Both my fiancee and I found this film excellent! It is truly artistic, and especially from the director’s commentary on the DVD—you can tell they put their whole hearts into the movie. Parents could certainly show their mature-minded child this film. It would be a fantastic jumping-off point for discussions of valour in combat, dedication, cameraderie, and bravery. There is nothing gratuitous, and for example, the directors expressly excluded the fact of pilots smoking cigarettes from the film just so that it would not be glorified along with the pilots. I’m a military pilot myself and I think this is a true tribute to the heart of an honourable pilot. The effects were spectacular and, while the film runs 2:19, it never feels long nor rushed. Finally, it was not, like so many Hollywood war films, bent on glorifing a biased view of an infallible America. It had a real and balanced story. Inspiring! Enjoy!
My Ratings: Moral rating: Excellent! / Moviemaking quality: 5
—Danny Vanderbyl, age 25