Reviewed by: Andrew Amick
How does viewing violence in movies affect the family? Answer
|Featuring:||Gaspard Ulliel, Gong Li, Rhys Ifans, Ivan Marevich, Dominic West|
|Producer:||Tarak Ben Ammar, Dino de Laurentiis, Martha de Laurentiis|
|Distributor:||MGM, The Weinstein Company|
“It started with revenge.”
Why? Why? “Why” is the question motivating people to see this. Why is Hannibal the way he is? What is his side of the story? Needless to say, we can all guess what parts of his life have included.
From the very beginning, Hannibal and his family are alone during the war, and are seized by Nazis. Shortly after, the Nazis are killed, leaving Hannibal and his younger sister Mischa at home alone during the winter. Of course, their peace-at-home is broken when Russians invade the home, looking to stay alive, having lost all other allies. When food runs short and the freeze kills vegetation and even solidifies the bodies of other soldiers outside, the Russians need food. It’s either starve or survive. So who do they turn to for food? The children: Hannibal and Mischa. Hannibal escapes. Mischa is not so lucky.
Hannibal, now a young adult or older teenager (never specified), is later placed in a reform school (more like a camp) run by Russians. Hannibal, we discover, hardly talks, and has nightmare visions of the experience he had as a child. He escapes and finds refuge in his widowed aunt’s mansion in France, and so begins his journey of revenge that will take him to his original home, to medical school, and to Canada: to track down each and every Russian involved in the murder and slaughter of his younger sister. While the movie can be seen as a tale of revenge, it does show what began Hannibal’s streak of insanity and monstrousness.
For a movie of such ominous caliber, the violence is not extreme, but feels that way. In the beginning are the typical war scenes: intruding soldiers, bombs, tanks, etc. It is nothing that “Saving Private Ryan” hasn’t seen, and not even as gruesome. However, so comes the survive-or-die tactics of the Russians, as they all turn to Mischa, hatchet in hand, knowing what to do. The implications of these scenes is extremely graphic; no child-killing is shown, however we all know where Mischa is going as she steps out the door into the front lawn with the men.
For a movie so long, there are really only few long scenes of gruesome violence, including rope-chokes, stitches in the thumb, brutal sword-slashes and stabs, war-violence, and severed heads (implications of what happened). And as far as cannibalism itself, Hannibal is seen taking one bite out of a person’s face in his ballistic rage. The movie is, rather than a blood bath, extremely intense, psychologically heavy, and very tense even for the audience, as in any word Hannibal says, we can see has an undercurrent of rage and vengeance, and no amount of true heroism. The movie, while portraying Hannibal as protagonist, really has no “hero,” unless Hannibal’s widowed aunt (who is a very minor accomplice to Hannibal, trying to keep him safe) counts.
For a movie that focuses so hard on the intense, rage-filled mind of a monstrous killer, there is no sex; if anything, it is just implied in the circumstances. A few Russians are seen running what looks like a boat-house brothel, where women serve, are beaten, are used as toys. Hannibal himself comes very close to a sexual relationship, but this is cut off immediately and never referred to again. However, some of the sexuality lays in the language, as some of Hannibal’s adversaries use very foul language to antagonize Hannibal and his widowed aunt.
The spirit behind the movie is dark, intense, and psychologically terrifying. Every time someone crosses Hannibal, we can feel that Hannibal will certainly get his revenge, and not so cleanly, either. Revenge and hate is so powerful, that the movie adds extreme tension to the audience. I came out of the theatre with a slight headache and feeling very irritated and intense. The spirit is troubling. While inside us humans, we can say “Hannibal’s enemies got what they deserve,” we still cannot look at Hannibal as some kind of hero, as some kind of rescuer or memory-keeper of his young sister Mischa. The movie is driven by rage, blood lust, revenge, and hate.
Everyone has their story. And as much as Hollywood tries to turn every personality into a caricature, Christians need to be considerate of all points of view, all circumstances, all pasts, etc. We cannot judge a person for where they are now just because they’re maniacal or insane; we cannot be so quick to vilify. We can hate their actions, we can hate what they do, but the story surrounding that person and the person themselves should never be at the mercy of our judgment. Hannibal himself, though, betrays this ideal, simply stating that he could never forgive. He would kill the Russians, now 10 years later, who have families, or run their own business, and have left that war life behind them. He would be the polar opposite of a Christian at the moral level: he is wrathful, hateful, vengeful, and most of all: unforgiving. As humans, our “judgment” on other people is merely punishment, vengeance, ignorance, or any slew of unjust human emotions based on rocky foundations, for we don’t know every human’s heart. Only God does, and only he can see into the heart so clearly as to make a certain judgment.
In my opinion, the movie is not worth watching for those who would neither be able to take much violence or even mental burden. For Christians, the movie may not be very tasteful. All-in-all, the movie makes sense: it has good quality, the acting is superb, and in context—it all works out. However, for Christians, the movie may be far less than acceptable for someone looking not to indulge in rage or violence or mind twists. Implied child-deaths and torturous punishment laid on by Hannibal may be too much for someone’s mind to bear.
Bottom Line: The movie, as part of the Hannibal series, is a good one. It delivers the side of the big bad wolf, answering some of our deepest questions about why people do what they do. And in-context, every aspect of the movie is okay. However, its violence, its psychological pressure, and disturbing spirit can prove to be more than horrendous for a Christian to view. Just ask: Would Jesus see this movie with you?
Violence: Heavy / Profanity: Moderate / Sex/Nudity: Minor