Reviewed by: Taran Gingery
“Miracles are not possible,” some claim. Is this true? Answer
Is it logical to believe that the biblical miracles really happened? Answer
False miracles deceiving some Catholics—revealed in documentary movie: “Messages from Heaven”
Is Jesus Christ really God? Answer
Are there biblical examples of depression and how to deal with it? Answer
What should a Christian do if overwhelmed with depression? Answer
Are you good enough to get to Heaven? Answer
How good is good enough? Answer
‘The Royal Tenenbaums,’ ‘Old School’
Dan Callahan, Earl Carroll, Noah Dahl, Gizza Elizondo, Elaine Anne Furst, Gloria Garayua, Beth Grant, Molly Hagan, Cheryl Hines, Marcus Maria Jung, Michelle Krusiec, Morgan Lily, George Lopez, Stephanie Mace, Kate Mulligan, Andrew Santino, Rachel Seiferth, Don Smith
|Director:|| Mark Pellington
“Arlington Road,” “The Mothman Prophecies”
|Producer:||Michael Aguilar, Beth DePatie, Gary Gilbert, David Kern, Gary Lucchesi, Eric Reid, Norman Reiss, Tom Rosenberg, Richard S. Wright|
“Changing his attitude will take a miracle.”
Most people who move into a new neighborhood are usually at least friendly towards their new neighbors. Not so with Henry Poole (Luke Wilson). Henry just wants to be left alone. He even tells everyone that it doesn’t matter what they do, as he won’t be in his new little house in Los Angeles long enough for it to make any difference. He is a rude, angry and sad man, although he won’t say why.
None of this deters his next-door neighbor, Esperanza Martinez (Adriana Barraza), who refuses to leave him alone, bringing him hot tamales and coming around every so often to check on him. Henry calls it being nosy, but Esperanza, a devout Catholic, believes that “those without faith need help the most.” So, when a mysterious water stain appears on the back wall of Henry’s house, Esperanza is convinced that it is in the shape of the face of Christ and therefore a miracle.
Henry is highly skeptical, accusing Esperanza of using her faith as a “vain hope” and largely ignores her and her pleas for his belief in favor of his other neighbors, Dawn (Rahda Mitchell) and her strangely silent daughter Millie (Morgan Lily), who records everything everyone says on cassette tapes. But as strange occurrences happen surrounding the watermark, Henry is forced to reexamine his beliefs and come to conclusions that will change his life forever.
First and foremost, it is important to say that this film never pokes fun at Christianity. Sure, Esperanza and her cronies are slightly eccentric in an endearing way, but they are never treated disrespectfully. The audience is never shown the watermark clearly enough to tell whether it is the face of Christ or not, but it is clear that the characters believe that it is, and we are invited to believe the same thing. The mark eventually starts to bleed and miracles of healing surround it. I believe in reality any such “mark” should be taken with a grain of salt, but for the purposes of the film, it serves as a powerful symbol.
The character of Henry Poole, played brilliantly by Wilson, refuses to believe the image has any power at all or that there even is an image. His stubbornness and resolve to explain away what he sees with his own eyes as “coincidences” are there for reasons I won’t give away, but let’s just say that Henry has a powerful argument for losing his faith. Eventually, though, through his relationships with Dawn, Esperanza and especially the estranged little Millie, we witness a man, broken and lonely, open up what is on his heart, come to terms with his past and, quite possible, with God.
Other characters are equally strong. Esperanza is a woman of faith, who, although having to deal with her own grief, firmly believes in the power of prayer, the ability of God to work through every situation, even bad situations, and the importance of helping others. Dawn, in offering a listening ear and an open heart, is key to Henry’s emotional revival. Also of note, George Lopez in a brief role portrays Father Salazar as a compassionate and understanding man as well as a leader in the community. The importance of having both parents present for a healthy family is emphasized.
So, is there anything negative in this beautiful and uplifting little film? Unfortunately, yes. Some foul language is present, including a couple of s-words, and Henry often misuses the Lord’s name, as do a few others. Henry and Dawn’s relationship remains chaste, with only a few kisses and hand-holding, but Dawn does wear slightly revealing attire. In anger, Henry smashes the wall of his own house, causing part of it to collapse on him, putting him in the hospital.
In spite of those things, however, I highly recommend this film to any Christian, although it’s not for the younger kids, who would probably be bored by it anyway. The power of this story of a man’s journey of faith is both realistic and reverent and is ultimately a story worth hearing.
Violence: Mild / Profanity: Moderate / Sex/Nudity: Minor
See list of Relevant Issues—questions-and-answers.