Today’s Prayer Focus
MOVIE REVIEW
The Chronicles of Narnia: The Lion, The Witch and The Wardrobe
also known as “As Crónicas de Nárnia: O Leão, a Feiticeira e o Guarda-Roupa,” “As Crônicas de Nárnia: O Leão, a Feiticeira e o Guarda-Roupa,” See all »
MPA Rating:
for battle sequences and frightening moments.
for battle sequences and frightening moments.
Reviewed by: Chris Monroe
STAFF WRITER
| Moral Rating: | Good |
| Moviemaking Quality: |
|
| Primary Audience: | Family Kids (but not very young children) |
| Genre: | Fantasy Action Adventure Kids Family |
| Length: | 2 hr. 23 min. |
| Year of Release: | 2005 |
| USA Release: |
December 9, 2005 (wide) |
Relevant Issues
Our INTERVIEW with the director and producer, plus the White Witch
How can I be (and feel) forgiven for what I’ve done wrong? Answer
If God forgives me every time I ask, why do I still feel so guilty? Answer
The story of God’s promise for all people—told beautifully and clearly from the beginning. Discover The HOPE!
If God created Satan, and Satan is evil, is evil God’s fault? Answer
What is the Christian perspective on war? Answer
Kids! Discover Kid Explorers—our fun site with animals and the rainforest—where you can discover answers to your questions, play games, activities, on-line movies and more.
Teens! Have questions? Find answers in our popular TeenQs section. Get answers to your questions about life, dating and much more.
| Featuring |
Georgie Henley … Lucy Pevensie Skandar Keynes … Edmund Pevensie William Moseley … Peter Pevensie Anna Popplewell … Susan Pevensie Tilda Swinton … White Witch James McAvoy … Mr. Tumnus Jim Broadbent … Professor Kirke James Cosmo … Father Christmas See all » |
| Director |
Andrew Adamson |
| Producer | Philip Steuer, Perry Moore, Mark Johnson |
| Distributor |
“There are a thousand stories in the land of Narnia… The first is about to be told.”
Finally, the long awaited, much anticipated adaptation of the beloved children’s story from The Chronicles of Narnia come to the big screen. This second of seven books from the series authored by C.S. Lewis over fifty years ago creates the substance with which this film, The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe mystifies, mesmerizes, enlightens and entertains anyone who is willing to embrace it. Doors to your imagination will unavoidably be opened—as might a door to your very heart and soul.
A wonderful adventure. An illustrious biblical metaphor. A beautiful Christmas story. A captivating fantasy. From the very heart of renowned Christian apologetic C.S. Lewis is the story of four children, Peter (William Moseley), Susan (Anna Popplewell), Edmund (Skandar Keynes) and Lucy (Georgie Henley) who discover a world they would have never thought possible. It’s World War II and these siblings are sent away for safe keeping into the English countryside to stay with a delightful old professor (Jim Broadbent) until danger subsides at their home in London. But after an unexpected discovery in the back of a coat closet, Lucy introduces her brothers and sister to a realm of make-believe that is more fun than any fantasy and more real than life and death. It is a world that provides friends and enemies, battles and betrayals, family unity and sacrifice, and a promise to become a king or queen.
But is the film The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe like the book? Director Andrew Adamson (“Shrek”, “Shrek II”) says that what you get from the book is what you will get from the movie. This does not mean Adamson did not make changes, however (see our interview article for more on this). But this movie has been made by all kinds of different people and companies, from all different backgrounds and walks of life and various worldviews. Did not some things have to change in order for a movie like this to be released into the mainstream media? Yes, there are changes, but ardent fans that have cherished these books for decades can rest assured knowing that these filmmakers remain faithful to its origins. The characters, storyline, themes and creativity all remain intact from the original charming children’s story.
For those who have not read The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe there may be questions as to what kind of children’s story this is exactly, involving battles and betrayals, a White Witch and “deep magic.” Is this just more Harry Potter? No, it is not, and it is definitely a story for kids (perhaps no younger than 7)—as well as for anyone who is willing to become like a child and enjoy it. Like so many great stories, this one is not about glorifying what is evil, but instead showing the triumph of what is good. There is the evil White Witch (Tilda Swinton), but there is also the great Lion and King of Narnia, Aslan (voice of Liam Neeson), whom Swinton describes as the “epitome of all good.”
One of the producing companies for this film is Disney, and as with so many of their children’s stories there is a noble effort to filter violence and curtail any incident that could be harmful or disturbing for younger kids. For instance, on different occasions when someone is killed, the incident is inferred rather than being gratuitously depicted. There are depictions of wounds being incurred during the furious battle scene, but there is no recollection of any blood being shown. The moments go by quick and should not be too overwhelming. The most frightening moment, however, is when Aslan goes to the stone table and passes through a host of scary creatures.
So what is it with this story that believers in Christ are so eager to connect? Is there a deeper meaning? Is the “deep magic” a reference to something else? Producer Mark Johnson (“Rain Man”, “Avalon”, “The Rookie”, “The Notebook”) says that so many of them read these books as kids and only thought of it as a good children’s story. But, Johnson says, C.S. Lewis was obviously a Christian, as well as a Christian writer, and states, “If you want to find all kinds of Christian symbolism in it, it’s certainly there.” Without going through the entire movie and interpreting point for point what those parallels are, suffice it to say that significant metaphors resound throughout this story, namely having the faith of a child, the sacrificial death of Jesus Christ, as well as His resurrection from the dead, resulting in salvation for sinners.
Is the goal then for making The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe to produce a “Christian” movie? Perhaps for some, but, as Johnson also points out, C.S. Lewis himself said that his book was not a “Christian” book. If you are a believer in Christ, you will most likely see the parallels to Jesus and the Gospel, but this movie can certainly be enjoyed by anyone who watches it.
If you are not familiar with the Gospel, but are somehow intrigued or interested, this story is a very delightful way to open up your heart and mind to it in an indirect way and cause you to consider the Good News as you may never have before.
Further, in light of the Gospel, it is highly appropriate that The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe is a children’s story, because as Jesus said, “I tell you the truth, unless you change and become like little children, you will never enter the kingdom of heaven. Therefore, whoever humbles himself like this little child is the greatest in the kingdom of heaven” (Matthew 18:3, NIV). Lucy is the youngest of the four children, and also the first to discover Narnia. When I asked actress Georgie Henley, who plays Lucy, what she liked best about her character, she said, “I loved her because she is so pure; very, very pure—and I think that is a gorgeous quality to have.”
This movie is a faithful adaptation and provides high quality, wholesome entertainment. You may not get everything from the movie that you get from the book, but the essence is there. It feels like there is more heart that comes through in the book, but while watching the film there is still the feeling of a grandfather divulging a significant tale to his grandchildren. Fans of the book should not be disappointed, and when considering a movie for the family at Christmas time, this one will refresh and delight like the first fall of winter snow.
Violence: Mild / Profanity: None / Sex/Nudity: None
Don’t miss our Relevant Issues list, plus our Narnia discovery list. Also, see our INTERVIEW: Behind the scenes of The Chronicles of Narnia with director Andrew Adamson, producer Mark Johnson, and actress Tilda Swinton (the White Witch)
Reviews of Sequels
The Chronicles of Narnia: Prince Caspian (2008)
The Chronicles of Narnia: The Voyage of the Dawn Treader (2010)
Positive
Positive—My 12 and 14 year old sons, husband and I saw this film together last night at a “sneak peak.” How refreshing! The splendidly done film stayed true to the book! It was perfectly cast (adorable children!), great acting, and wonderful effects. I refuse to believe those animals were computer generated! Of course, the message behind the story was the best part. This film was more than a “5”—a must see for everyone!
Excellent! / 5
Excellent! / 5
Julie Schopp, age 44
Discover more!
Answers to your skeptical questions about Jesus Christ. Who was he? Read the record, examine the evidence for his divinity, miracles, resurrection and claims
What will the biblical Millennium be like?
(the future thousand-year reign of Christ on Earth)
Coloring page: The lion and the lamb
Positive—As I heard Narnia for the first time as a child, I sat with sketching pad and pencil in hand, drawing the wonderful worlds the author painted in my mind. Years later, these images remain as strong as they once were, in a book as familiar to me as a wind’s somber whisper. The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe was one of, if not the, favorite book of my childhood. When I learned my favorite story of all time was coming to the silver screen, I prayed it would be wonderful. I was not disappointed.
Both as a fan of CS Lewis and his book series, I was absolutely enthralled with their depiction of one of the greatest children’s stories of all time. Lewis' power lay in simplifying a story that is as familiar to many of us as breathing and translating it in such a way that each time it is revisited, it feels as though you have never encountered it before. The film is one of the mightiest, most compelling adaptations of a book that I have ever seen. Built on the solid foundation of Lewis' epic story of good and evil, it breathes life into the characters he envisioned. I would not change a single thing about it, and that’s extremely rare in film making. First, the casting is absolute brilliance. Each of the children are rich with personality. Peter and his genuine desire to be heroic. Susan and her determination to mother the others. Edmund and his numerous doubts and fears. Lucy, and her trusting innocence, the virtue that lead her to Narnia to begin with.See all »
Excellent! / 5
Both as a fan of CS Lewis and his book series, I was absolutely enthralled with their depiction of one of the greatest children’s stories of all time. Lewis' power lay in simplifying a story that is as familiar to many of us as breathing and translating it in such a way that each time it is revisited, it feels as though you have never encountered it before. The film is one of the mightiest, most compelling adaptations of a book that I have ever seen. Built on the solid foundation of Lewis' epic story of good and evil, it breathes life into the characters he envisioned. I would not change a single thing about it, and that’s extremely rare in film making. First, the casting is absolute brilliance. Each of the children are rich with personality. Peter and his genuine desire to be heroic. Susan and her determination to mother the others. Edmund and his numerous doubts and fears. Lucy, and her trusting innocence, the virtue that lead her to Narnia to begin with.See all »
Excellent! / 5
Charity Bishop, age 22
Positive—…“Does the cinematic version of… do justice to the literary masterpiece written by CS Lewis?”. We all stood by in questioning anticipation prior to the release of “The Passion of the Christ,” wondering how Hollywood or shall I say, Mel Gibson would represent Jesus Christ. Then the world dropped their jaw at the gut-wrenching sacrifice that Christ went through and the impact the movie depiction had on the world. Collectively and as one unified body, we all lifted our hands in praise and delight. Now we have the Chronicles of Narnia, which was intended to not only be an escape into the land of fantasy and fun but a teaching mechanism to show the sacrifice and love that Jesus has for mankind. The question of the movie giving credibility to CS Lewis and the Bible is nothing less than a resounding YES! The movie in my opinion, will be compared to the Passion of the Christ and may in fact reach more people because of its rating and storyline. I sincerely hope at least. I was asked by someone after the movie, if I felt the film was an “in your face” approach to the Christian aspect of the movie. My answer was, “If you can can’t see Christ in this movie then you must be blind. You cannot get more in your face than this movie.” CS Lewis’s character “Aslan” is hitting the mainstream in movie format will show that Jesus’s name in fictional format will give Jesus Christ His do credence.
The Chronicles of Narnia, The Lion the Witch and the Wardrobe is the story of 4 children who find a secret doorway into another world via the access of a Coat Closet or Wardrobe in one of the spare bedrooms. This world is called Narnia. Once arriving in Narnia, they are faced with being sought by an army led by the ruler of the land, named “The White Witch.” There is an unfulfilled prophecy of 4 human who will lead an army against the White Witch and with the help of the Great King Aslan will free the world from bondage and the Witch’s enslavery. Such prophecy will also lead to the end of a 100 year winter brought on by the White Witch. Because of this prophecy, the White Witch puts a price on the head of all humans who may come into Narnia and anyone who helps one will be turned to stone.See all »
Excellent! / 5
The Chronicles of Narnia, The Lion the Witch and the Wardrobe is the story of 4 children who find a secret doorway into another world via the access of a Coat Closet or Wardrobe in one of the spare bedrooms. This world is called Narnia. Once arriving in Narnia, they are faced with being sought by an army led by the ruler of the land, named “The White Witch.” There is an unfulfilled prophecy of 4 human who will lead an army against the White Witch and with the help of the Great King Aslan will free the world from bondage and the Witch’s enslavery. Such prophecy will also lead to the end of a 100 year winter brought on by the White Witch. Because of this prophecy, the White Witch puts a price on the head of all humans who may come into Narnia and anyone who helps one will be turned to stone.See all »
Excellent! / 5
John Kehrli, age 31
Positive—…I am one of the judges for the Heartland Film Festival that screens films for their Truly Moving Picture Award. A Truly Moving Picture “…explores the human journey by artistically expressing hope and respect for the positive values of life.” Heartland gave that award to this film.
Four young children enter the timeless world of Narnia through the door of a wardrobe piece of furniture while playing hide-and-seek. And what a world it is. There are talking animals, dwarfs, giants, beasts, centaurs, and indescribable half-human combinations. And, in this world of Narnia there is a titanic struggle between the White Witch and her evil army and the good lion Aslan and his noble army.
Although it doesn’t seem possible, you can suspend disbelief and become engaged in the story because the artistry and technology are so outstanding. The art direction, special effects, cinematography, editing and sound will most likely and should be nominated for Academy Awards. The lion Aslan dominates your attention in every scene he appears in, and as the story unfolds, he becomes as human-like as any of the four children.
The four children seem normal enough with their constant teasing and fighting among themselves, but when events truly matter, they come together and exemplify the highest standards of sacrifice, courage, fidelity and heroism. Both children and adults will find inspiration and role models in these four children.
The lion Aslan is like Christ. There are many parallels between Aslan and Christ, and you can watch this film anywhere in the religious-secular spectrum you care to. I suspect that over many years the other six books that make up The Chronicles of Narnia will be made into movies, and they will have the same type of financial and artistic success as “The Lord of the Rings” film trilogy had. That is high praise indeed.
Take your whole family to support this movie so they will make the other six “Narnia” book into movies. Your kids will love it.
Good / 5
Four young children enter the timeless world of Narnia through the door of a wardrobe piece of furniture while playing hide-and-seek. And what a world it is. There are talking animals, dwarfs, giants, beasts, centaurs, and indescribable half-human combinations. And, in this world of Narnia there is a titanic struggle between the White Witch and her evil army and the good lion Aslan and his noble army.
Although it doesn’t seem possible, you can suspend disbelief and become engaged in the story because the artistry and technology are so outstanding. The art direction, special effects, cinematography, editing and sound will most likely and should be nominated for Academy Awards. The lion Aslan dominates your attention in every scene he appears in, and as the story unfolds, he becomes as human-like as any of the four children.
The four children seem normal enough with their constant teasing and fighting among themselves, but when events truly matter, they come together and exemplify the highest standards of sacrifice, courage, fidelity and heroism. Both children and adults will find inspiration and role models in these four children.
The lion Aslan is like Christ. There are many parallels between Aslan and Christ, and you can watch this film anywhere in the religious-secular spectrum you care to. I suspect that over many years the other six books that make up The Chronicles of Narnia will be made into movies, and they will have the same type of financial and artistic success as “The Lord of the Rings” film trilogy had. That is high praise indeed.
Take your whole family to support this movie so they will make the other six “Narnia” book into movies. Your kids will love it.
Good / 5
Bob Stem, age 19
Positive—…I had the great privilege yesterday of seeing the highly anticipated The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe from Disney/Walden. I haven’t been so eager to see a film since “The Passion of the Christ”, nor felt the same sense of relief and joy! The movie is lovely.Narnia is a wonderland. The kids are going to love it. They are going to want to walk through that wardrobe with Lucy time after time.the tone of LW&W is as close to the book as probably could have been achieved. All the lines the Christians are worrying about are in there. All the scenes you want to see are here and lovingly rendered. So everybody can relax and get ready to enjoy… I personally cried every moment Aslan was on the screen… People were saying 8 year olds could handle it fine. I agree. But I also think littler kids should go… Bring your kids to see The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe! Bring them again!”…
Barbara Nicolosi, Act One (director and screenwriter)
Positive—This film was simply amazing. ’Twas an epic… a thrill ride from start to finish. It was wholesome—a good, edifying film. I felt uplifted by this film; nowadays, my spirit is affected by the mire of language, sensuality, etc. common to so many movies these days. In fact, the rhetoric in this masterpiece was pure and even eloquent at times. The war violence is not gratuitous nor prolonged.
The acting was superb; the child actors in this film were BELIEVABLE. They aptly captured the characters they portrayed. And that’s just that! THEY HAD CHARACTER! And it was more and more real and ostensible as the movie progressed. We all fell in love with the adorable, darling cute Lucy. We begrudged the selfish, wily Edmond, and yet we were moved to compassion for his humanness. We were amused by the antics of the intelligent, yet unassured Susan, and we rooted for the gallant, young hero Peter who shouldered the family, and ultimately, Narnia. The other characters were powerful as well, from Mr. Tumnus to Mr. and Mrs. Beaver to Aslan to even the dark and terrifying White Witch.
While watching this movie, it was clear the filmmakers preserved the apparent parallels to Christ with which C.S. Lewis imbued his opus. Truly, it was magnificent! I came home, nearly at 3 in the morning, and all that came to mind was John 15:13: “Greater love hath no man than this, that a man lay down his life for his friends.” These were the words of Jesus; he sacrificed himself for ALL OF US. In particular, He had (and has) such GREAT LOVE for ME! So great a love that he would DIE in my stead! Truly amazing. Just simply amazing. I believe (and it is my prayer) that this film will actually move fence-sitters to find the God of the Universe who intimately loves them.
Excellent! / 5
The acting was superb; the child actors in this film were BELIEVABLE. They aptly captured the characters they portrayed. And that’s just that! THEY HAD CHARACTER! And it was more and more real and ostensible as the movie progressed. We all fell in love with the adorable, darling cute Lucy. We begrudged the selfish, wily Edmond, and yet we were moved to compassion for his humanness. We were amused by the antics of the intelligent, yet unassured Susan, and we rooted for the gallant, young hero Peter who shouldered the family, and ultimately, Narnia. The other characters were powerful as well, from Mr. Tumnus to Mr. and Mrs. Beaver to Aslan to even the dark and terrifying White Witch.
While watching this movie, it was clear the filmmakers preserved the apparent parallels to Christ with which C.S. Lewis imbued his opus. Truly, it was magnificent! I came home, nearly at 3 in the morning, and all that came to mind was John 15:13: “Greater love hath no man than this, that a man lay down his life for his friends.” These were the words of Jesus; he sacrificed himself for ALL OF US. In particular, He had (and has) such GREAT LOVE for ME! So great a love that he would DIE in my stead! Truly amazing. Just simply amazing. I believe (and it is my prayer) that this film will actually move fence-sitters to find the God of the Universe who intimately loves them.
Excellent! / 5
Jacob Keenum, age 19
Positive—…Just over a week ago, a team from the Mission America Coalition joined other leaders from around the country to view a rough cut of The Chronicles of Narnia: The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe… They got it right… The imagery of this film is compelling, as is the opportunity to explain its true meaning to seekers in our own generation… we urge churches and ministries to take full advantage of the movie’s release… Aslan is on the move. …
Jim Overholt (Executive Director, The Mission America Coalition)
Positive—…At the Disney lot I recently saw a full, rough cut version of Walden Media’s new film The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe. I went in with some trepidation, wondering whether the heart of the story would be left intact. I was not only satisfied that it was; I felt the redemptive message was even stronger than I’d hoped. …
Scott Evans (founder and president of Outreach, Inc.)
Positive—…This film has everything Christians have sought in a movie—it is well-written, well-acted and it contains a solid metaphor for Jesus Christ in the person of Aslan the lion that is subtle enough to stimulate conversation with unbelievers. It is a powerful film. I saw it last Friday night at a screening in New York and tears came to my eyes; not only because of the content, but because Walden Media and Disney have teamed up to give us something we can cheer and support. …
Cal Thomas (syndicated columnist)
Positive—…The movie was very well cast and the computer characters and effects were of high caliber. The music was overall good, although sometimes it was hard to hear what the lyrics were. I frankly think that it should have been rated somewhere between PG and PG-13 because several of the moments are tense, frightening, or just down right creepy. I was impressed how there was also an amazing amount of humor that helped to make the film lighter. I loved Mr. and Mrs. Beaver! I was shocked at some of the parents in the audience for bringing their children who were 2-6 years old (all I can say is “not my child” when I’m a parent). Honestly, I would not think of bringing a child any younger than 10 years old to view it. Also be aware of the fact that you should bring Kleenex to the theatre, for I was regretting several times that I didn’t bring any. The one main thing which disturbed me was the scene where Aslan is killed by the White Witch. It is an incredibly moving section, and I wanted to jump up and present the Gospel to the audience, for I know that some of the families there only thought of it as “good children’s literature.” Oh, the simple truth that ONE really did love us “traitors” so much that He did sacrifice Himself… and then rose from the dead!
Two last insights: 1) It is so fascinating that in Narnia years-and-years are only split seconds in Earth-bound years—kind of reminded me of how it will be in heaven. Time will go on and on and on! 2) The inward journey that the four children make towards being an actual family will leave you wanting to tell your mother and father how much you love them, but even more, you will want to tell your brothers and sisters that!!
Better than Average / 4
Two last insights: 1) It is so fascinating that in Narnia years-and-years are only split seconds in Earth-bound years—kind of reminded me of how it will be in heaven. Time will go on and on and on! 2) The inward journey that the four children make towards being an actual family will leave you wanting to tell your mother and father how much you love them, but even more, you will want to tell your brothers and sisters that!!
Better than Average / 4
Cara, age 20
Positive—I took my two daughters (10 and 8) out of school to see this movie. We’ve been watching the preparations for almost 2 years and have been praying fervently that it would change lives in the viewers. Great movie.
I would not recommend taking young children, and though my 4 year old wants to see it, I won’t take my own preschooler. The violence is presented accurately, but is “blood-less” and done tastefully so as not to darken the movie. There are a few places—a wolf unexpectedly appearing, evil army members, etc.—that caught my kids off-guard. Aslan is a little tame for a lion who isn’t tame, and there are some additions to the story, but the message is clear, and this piece of art is beautiful. Regardless of critics’ comments, the Biblical overtones are precious and give the movie incredible value as a witnessing tool.
If this film doesn’t win Disney awards for costuming, set design, special effects and graphics, and acting (Susan next to Aslan at the Stone Table is moving, as is the change in Edmund), something is wrong with Hollywood. If this doesn’t bring in box-office records, something is wrong with us, the viewers! We need to strongly support this film and thank Disney for the presentation of a quality, accurate film that is good for the family and presents one of the greatest pieces of literature ever. We went this morning, and we will continue to see the movie in the theater as much as we can. Cannot wait for this one to hit stores on DVD either!
Excellent! / 5
I would not recommend taking young children, and though my 4 year old wants to see it, I won’t take my own preschooler. The violence is presented accurately, but is “blood-less” and done tastefully so as not to darken the movie. There are a few places—a wolf unexpectedly appearing, evil army members, etc.—that caught my kids off-guard. Aslan is a little tame for a lion who isn’t tame, and there are some additions to the story, but the message is clear, and this piece of art is beautiful. Regardless of critics’ comments, the Biblical overtones are precious and give the movie incredible value as a witnessing tool.
If this film doesn’t win Disney awards for costuming, set design, special effects and graphics, and acting (Susan next to Aslan at the Stone Table is moving, as is the change in Edmund), something is wrong with Hollywood. If this doesn’t bring in box-office records, something is wrong with us, the viewers! We need to strongly support this film and thank Disney for the presentation of a quality, accurate film that is good for the family and presents one of the greatest pieces of literature ever. We went this morning, and we will continue to see the movie in the theater as much as we can. Cannot wait for this one to hit stores on DVD either!
Excellent! / 5
Carie Lambert, age 34
Positive—I am a huge fan of the books and was eagerly awaiting this movie. It did not disappoint in the least! “The Chronicles of Narnia” is one of the my favorite series, and I was so pleased that my favorite book, Lion Witch and Wardrobe, remained accurate and true to CS Lewis’ vision. …the actors were all wonderful and true to what I had imagined them to be. I enjoyed watching the movie and reading the books to find the allegory of Christ and everytime I re-read and watch the movies I find more. It keeps the book alive and also represents the growth of my faith. It was nice to see a movie that is fun and so spiritual, if you take the time to look for it. I hope the growing trend in Hollywood is to produce more movies like this one! I recommend this movie for all ages (except very young) and for both fans of the series and people new to Narnia!
Excellent! / 5
Excellent! / 5
Bridget, age 22
Positive—Having waited for this movie for five years, since I first heard about a screenplay in the works. To all the amazing sneak peaks, my deepest fear was that Chronicles would be like the Disney versions of Madelene L’Engle’s books. Thankfully my fears are un founded. Have seen this movie twice, I could not be more thrilled on the acting, special effects, and of course Aslan. The acting and screenplay are fantastic (for there was talk of making this set in California and having the turkish delight be cheese burgers), the highlight is the adding of scenes for Mr. Tumnus’s character. James McAvey and Georgie Henely are amazing together, and they really portray the friendship much better then the book does. Aslan is so beautifully cinemized, it is impossible to take your eyes off of him during the scenes he is in. All in all, nothing can be said to detract from this movie, it is pure cinematic, and movie adaptation genius, and hopefully we will see more “Chronicles of Narnia” movies in the near future.
Good / 5
Good / 5
Jennie, age 18
Positive—Fantastic! Well worth the wait! Disney has positively surprised! Excellent moral rating: inspite of scary creatures on the witch’s side—evil is ugly and should be frightening! Not for children under 7 or 8. (I sat next to a family with a 5 or 6 year old that cried repeatedly at the evil guys—not fun for her parents or those close by). Left out a few things and add a few things (including adding scripture at a pivotal point! Amen!), but the story and message remains well intact. Highly enjoyable by all ages—not just a children’s movie! Wonderful cast! Repeatedly watchable!
Excellent! / 5
Excellent! / 5
Charity, age 29
Positive—INCREDIBLE MOVIE—From the animation, the story telling, the acting, the adaptation of C.S. Lewis’s writing, etc. …Throughout the movie I continued to think about Christ and the sacrifice he made for me, which is what C.S. Lewis intended. It amazed me that Disney put this picture out without tampering with the story or trying to hide/avoid the meaning behind the story. Like I said “INCREDIBLE MOVIE”…
Excellent! / 5
Excellent! / 5
Brad, age 34
Positive—…The first book in the Chronicles of Narnia is The Magician’s Nephew which tells the story of how Narnia came to be. How the White Witch came to be there and what started the whole thing. From the creation to the fall of Adam to how the wardrobe came to be where it ended up. …
Excellent! / 5
Excellent! / 5
Jennifer, age 31
Positive—…It was well done, with great effects, and a very plausible story-line. They certainly captured the heart of the movie. I intend to go again. For standing on a fence, it is a truly magnificent, grand and spectacular film. I imagined the events in the book, but the makers of a movie have a more vivid imagination than I do, and they made it more wonderful than I had imagined. I loved how they worked statues, and winter, and the size and depth of Narnia. They capture the essence of the beavers well. I like how they made giants, and they also made non vaporware bad-guys. They were plausible, and strong enough to be an adversary, something that many tales lack. It was very well done.
As someone who read the books deeply and well as an adult, and has a pretty solid grip on CS Lewis’ Christian content, I feel that the movie-makers missed much of the soul. The lion is made supernatural, but not divine. In order to understand Aslan as Mr. Lewis understands him, you must understand Jesus how CS Lewis understood him, because Jesus was the prototype for Aslan, or Aslan is a type for Jesus. Though the film writers are good at making the most of a text-media story transfer to a visual-media story they do not have a solid mastery of the character, alien-wildness, or deep down goodness of Jesus. Its a great adventure, but its like they tried to make it at a bridge between two worlds, the church and the un-church and so it steps fully into neither. I hope that in the next story they capture the Jesus-ness of Aslan.
Hey, first weekend this is the 3rd highest grossing movie of the year, a little more attendance, and we can expect a sequel. How often is it, outside of target-kid only Big Ideas, that you get a great solid movie that Christian adults and christian kids can love?
Good / 5
As someone who read the books deeply and well as an adult, and has a pretty solid grip on CS Lewis’ Christian content, I feel that the movie-makers missed much of the soul. The lion is made supernatural, but not divine. In order to understand Aslan as Mr. Lewis understands him, you must understand Jesus how CS Lewis understood him, because Jesus was the prototype for Aslan, or Aslan is a type for Jesus. Though the film writers are good at making the most of a text-media story transfer to a visual-media story they do not have a solid mastery of the character, alien-wildness, or deep down goodness of Jesus. Its a great adventure, but its like they tried to make it at a bridge between two worlds, the church and the un-church and so it steps fully into neither. I hope that in the next story they capture the Jesus-ness of Aslan.
Hey, first weekend this is the 3rd highest grossing movie of the year, a little more attendance, and we can expect a sequel. How often is it, outside of target-kid only Big Ideas, that you get a great solid movie that Christian adults and christian kids can love?
Good / 5
Mike Munroe, age 31
Positive—…I loved it, my kids loved it, my husband loved it. I read this as a child, read it to my daughter (the whole series) when she was 9, and now am in the third book with my son who is now 9. This movie, with some minor changes, remained intact with the message intended clearly given. I pray my non-Christian friends watch this movie and start asking me questions so we may all have the hope and peace of knowing that life on Earth is not all there is to living… “It is finished”!
Excellent! / 5
Excellent! / 5
Tiffany, age 38
Positive—Amazing! I took my 14, 12 and 5 year old to see this movie. I was hesitant to take my five year old because of the death of Aslan I knew was sure to be shown. My husband and I are extremely careful about what we allow our our children to see, but we felt this was a good parable for our 5 yr. old to see, so she could liken it to the story of Jesus—we could use it as a teaching tool.
We thoroughly enjoyed the movie. I liked how it was unbloody and not gory at all; even the Aslan/stone table scene was gentle for little eyes. Rachael, our 5 yr old, was upset when Tummnus was turned to stone and when Aslan was at the stone table, but when I reassured her each time, that Aslan would come back to life, like Jesus did and that he would make everything new, she smiled and was okay.
Those reviewers who are concerned that there is a lack of focus on the parallels need to remember that DISNEY IS NOT CHRISTIAN! It is not Disneys intent to preach the gospel, in fact, Disney is one of the most unchristian organizations out there! There goal is to make money and it is my personal belief that they were thinking… mmmmm magic, the public likes magic… lets make some money on this one. This is also a PERFECT example of how God takes the work of unbelievers and uses it to accomplish HIS goals to spread the gospel of JESUS CHRIST!
With that being said, my kids and I are going to do a unit study on Narnia. Homeschool with the little ones and a bible class on Wed. nights with me on Narnia and its theological meanings and parallels. If you have not discovered the free curriculum online yet, it is thenarniaacademy.org and it is fantastic and a great resource. Be blessed and use this movie as an evangelical tool to spread the gospel of our savior and king!
“I have found a desire within myself that no experience in THIS world can satisfy. The most probable explanation is that I was made for another world.” C.S. Lewis
Excellent! / 5
We thoroughly enjoyed the movie. I liked how it was unbloody and not gory at all; even the Aslan/stone table scene was gentle for little eyes. Rachael, our 5 yr old, was upset when Tummnus was turned to stone and when Aslan was at the stone table, but when I reassured her each time, that Aslan would come back to life, like Jesus did and that he would make everything new, she smiled and was okay.
Those reviewers who are concerned that there is a lack of focus on the parallels need to remember that DISNEY IS NOT CHRISTIAN! It is not Disneys intent to preach the gospel, in fact, Disney is one of the most unchristian organizations out there! There goal is to make money and it is my personal belief that they were thinking… mmmmm magic, the public likes magic… lets make some money on this one. This is also a PERFECT example of how God takes the work of unbelievers and uses it to accomplish HIS goals to spread the gospel of JESUS CHRIST!
With that being said, my kids and I are going to do a unit study on Narnia. Homeschool with the little ones and a bible class on Wed. nights with me on Narnia and its theological meanings and parallels. If you have not discovered the free curriculum online yet, it is thenarniaacademy.org and it is fantastic and a great resource. Be blessed and use this movie as an evangelical tool to spread the gospel of our savior and king!
“I have found a desire within myself that no experience in THIS world can satisfy. The most probable explanation is that I was made for another world.” C.S. Lewis
Excellent! / 5
Claire Guthrie, age 35
Positive—Narnia was truly a fantastic film from start to finish! The acting (all by mostly unknowns) was superb, the effects fantastic, and the story totally engrossing. I find it sad that some secular critics have trashed this film as “nothing more than a Christian tract.” The movie was made to faithfully realize C.S. Lewis’s vision, and does just that. It doesn’t cram anything down anyone’s throat, but Christians will appreciate the symbolism and allegorical references to Christ and forgiveness. Any adventure or fantasy fan will appreciate this movie. For younger viewers, I urge some caution, however, as the battle scenes are intense, and the various creatures could definitely be frightening to children. I must say, while I am not the type to be easily offended by objectionable content in films, it is always refreshing to see a movie succeed on such a tremendous level without resorting to language, sexuality, or excessive violence. Narnia has my vote for Best Picture this year!
Excellent! / 5
Excellent! / 5
Will, age 28
Positive—There are many things in life that are risky. It could be argued there are few things more risky than to take a classic novel and turn it into a screenplay. We saw this with “Lord of the Rings”. There was a lot of excitement surrounding the news of not one, but three movies being made for this trilogy, but it was coupled with apprehension. Questions were being asked. Are these movies going to stand up to the novel? Are the changes that were made going to adversely affect the story? If you can’t fit the whole novel in the movie, what are they going to leave out?
All fears were gone after The Fellowship of the Ring was released. Peter Jackson did a superb job and gave a fine example on how a classic novel should be translated to film.
Fans of The Chronicles of Narnia went through the same experience and should find themselves with the same result. The Lion, The Witch, and The Wardrobe…sets the bar for the other six. And it can be said with confidence, the bar is set pretty high.See all »
Excellent! / 4½
All fears were gone after The Fellowship of the Ring was released. Peter Jackson did a superb job and gave a fine example on how a classic novel should be translated to film.
Fans of The Chronicles of Narnia went through the same experience and should find themselves with the same result. The Lion, The Witch, and The Wardrobe…sets the bar for the other six. And it can be said with confidence, the bar is set pretty high.See all »
Excellent! / 4½
Matt Wells, age 31
Positive—The film as a whole was superb. I only wish that they had given it more time to develop the characters a little more (Aslan especially). I was relieved to see how well Lucy came across. The actress who portrayed Lucy without a doubt upped the film’s quality by several notches. I was also delighted to see James McAvoy (Rory O’Shea Was Here) as Tumnus. He was perfect for this role.
Of course Tilda Swinton (Constantine) turned in a wonderful performance as the White Witch. She shined in her opening scene with Edmund. I wish she had dialogue that was this good in the rest of the film though.
I’m looking forward to a possible extended cut DVD sometime in the future which might smooth out the few wrinkles in this movie. I loved the movie, but if anyone is looking for another “Lord Of The Rings”, you need to get out more. Narnia is a whole different animal, and not a tame one.
Better than Average / 4
Of course Tilda Swinton (Constantine) turned in a wonderful performance as the White Witch. She shined in her opening scene with Edmund. I wish she had dialogue that was this good in the rest of the film though.
I’m looking forward to a possible extended cut DVD sometime in the future which might smooth out the few wrinkles in this movie. I loved the movie, but if anyone is looking for another “Lord Of The Rings”, you need to get out more. Narnia is a whole different animal, and not a tame one.
Better than Average / 4
Cade Loven, age 19
Positive—My family and our friend’s family went to see Narnia this afternoon not knowing quite what to expect. We love the Narnia books and Focus on the Family Radio drama and were sort of worried about there being a watering down of the story and it’s closeness to the Gospel, and magic being promoted above truth and morality. We were therefore thrilled when we watched it this afternoon and saw the how close to the book it actually was and how plainly the death of Aslan reminded us of what Christ did on the cross, dying for us as Aslan died for Edmund. It was beautifully told, funny, charming, no bad words or sexual references, and though some of the battle scenes were a bit scary for the youngest of our group, we were surprised that we never saw any blood, even on Peter’s sword!
We all thoroughly enjoyed this movie and would recommend it to Christians everywhere. Be prepared if you have little ones for a few scary moments were little ones will want to hide their eyes though. I give this movie two thumbs up!
Good / 4
We all thoroughly enjoyed this movie and would recommend it to Christians everywhere. Be prepared if you have little ones for a few scary moments were little ones will want to hide their eyes though. I give this movie two thumbs up!
Good / 4
Laurie, age 18
Positive—Beautifully shot, wonderfully acted film. …The young actors were outstanding and engaging. For my older daughter (age 12), the biblical and spiritual allegories were evident. When we were in the car after the movie, I simply asked “Who was Aslan.” She replied, “Christ.” The witch was mean and Tilda Swinton played the part well. We all were amazed at how seamlessly the movie incorporates human and animal. In the opening battle charge, it is as though the cheetahs are truly running alongside centaurs and King Peter. The themes are many to talk about: sacrifice, when the innocent are harmed, the wrong decisions sin can cause you to make and the consequences of those decisions, love and devotion to family, empathy for the hurting and weak, hope in the face of insurmountable odds, faith, trusting someone at their word and the need to be faithful to your words, death is a part of the world, second chances provided by a loving Father, and that war (in the children’s life’s in London and in the world of Narnia) is a part of who we are as society. I hope this movie does well for we would like to see sequels from the Narnia Chronicles.
Excellent! / 5
Excellent! / 5
Jeff Mc, age 46
Positive—Excellent movie, near perfect transition from book. …I also found myself liking the actors because they don’t seem like actors but real kids, responding in a natural way. …
Excellent! / 5
Excellent! / 5
Brett Binder, age 28
Neutral
Neutral—…I usually have no problem with differences between book and movie versions because I recognize that they’re different mediums. However, in this movie, it seemed that they changed all the wrong scenes for all the wrong reasons. Before I continue, let me make one thing clear. You (and your kids) can probably go in and watch this movie on a superficial level and not have a problem with any of the issues that I’m talking about. That’s because I have a very analytical mind and I love to really analyze movies. On this superficial level—just watching it for fun, not really paying attention to details or picking everything apart—it’s a great Christian allegory with no sex, gory violence or bad words.
However, on a much more deeper perspective… if you really look at it… Adamson has taken a wonderful Christian allegory and turned it into a story about how important family is and self-sacrifice and love. (Not that family, self-sacrifice and love aren’t a part of Christianity, it’s just that he has isolated those qualities as an end to themselves.) Frankly, the emphasis is not on the Christian symbols and meanings but on the triumph of the individual. It seemed to me that he tried to undercut the Christian symbolism in the movie in every way possible—and on a much deeper level than the surface, he succeeded.
The battle scenes in the movie are okay. But my suggestion is that if you want to see a movie with a lot of battle scenes and a more honest Christian allegory, watch “The Lord of the Rings” trilogy; it surpasses Chronicles on every level. If you do want to see Chronicles, though, go into it knowing that, while it remains a great story that parallels the story of Christ, it is made by, for and in the secular Hollywood culture.
Good / 2
However, on a much more deeper perspective… if you really look at it… Adamson has taken a wonderful Christian allegory and turned it into a story about how important family is and self-sacrifice and love. (Not that family, self-sacrifice and love aren’t a part of Christianity, it’s just that he has isolated those qualities as an end to themselves.) Frankly, the emphasis is not on the Christian symbols and meanings but on the triumph of the individual. It seemed to me that he tried to undercut the Christian symbolism in the movie in every way possible—and on a much deeper level than the surface, he succeeded.
The battle scenes in the movie are okay. But my suggestion is that if you want to see a movie with a lot of battle scenes and a more honest Christian allegory, watch “The Lord of the Rings” trilogy; it surpasses Chronicles on every level. If you do want to see Chronicles, though, go into it knowing that, while it remains a great story that parallels the story of Christ, it is made by, for and in the secular Hollywood culture.
Good / 2
C. Gooch, age 18
Neutral—C. Gooch’s comments are on the money. I’ve probably read the Chronicles 10 times over since I was age 5 and say quite seriously that they are some of the most important theology (the study of the nature of God) that I’ve ever encountered. The main themes in the book are NOT a) personal empowerment; b) family solidarity; c) love of country; d) courage for freedom’s sake; e) inspiration through prophetic turn of events, etc. Rather, the main theme is the Person of Aslan. Aslan is not just an interesting character—EVERYTHING hinges upon Him. As Lucy sobs in Voyage of the Dawn Treader when Aslan says that they will not return to Narnia again, “It isn’t Narnia, you know… It’s you… How can we live, never meeting you?”
Peter does not do battle or kill Fenris Ulf because he conquers his fears and “decides” to rise above it, brave soul. Rather, he is in awe of Aslan, and Aslan says that he will do these things—thus he does them, feeling shaky nonetheless. And every obedience becomes an affirmation of Aslan’s word.See all »
Better than Average / 4
Peter does not do battle or kill Fenris Ulf because he conquers his fears and “decides” to rise above it, brave soul. Rather, he is in awe of Aslan, and Aslan says that he will do these things—thus he does them, feeling shaky nonetheless. And every obedience becomes an affirmation of Aslan’s word.See all »
Better than Average / 4
J Maier, age 38
Neutral—After enduring the very long wait for a big budget film adaptation of one of the most beloved books of the last decade, I must confess I am a bit disappointed. Allow me to clarify, as a typical Disney movie I found it perfect. I’ve watched a lot of Disney films over the years and this had Disney’s great acting, directing, and special effects, but it was not the grand epic I had hoped for. I’m not trying to be insensitive, but I found the characters to be somewhat superficial, without the depth say of Lord of the Rings. This will not be an academy award winner, but rather a fantastic book adapted into just another typical Disney production. Absolutely perfect for 8-13 year olds. Disappointment may follow hopeful adults that are expecting more.
I do want to praise the script writer and director for including C.S. Lewis’ trilemma (lunatic, liar or Lord) in reference to whether or not to believe Lucy. I was certain that they would have left it out. I was pleased to see it kept in the script, although it was a bit quick moving for most to pick up on.
Good / 4
I do want to praise the script writer and director for including C.S. Lewis’ trilemma (lunatic, liar or Lord) in reference to whether or not to believe Lucy. I was certain that they would have left it out. I was pleased to see it kept in the script, although it was a bit quick moving for most to pick up on.
Good / 4
JP, age 35
Negative
Negative—First let’s list the good things. A lot of believers were worried that the Christian viewpoint of the film would be lost or distorted in the transition to a Hollywood blockbuster type film. It hasn’t been The sacrifice on the stone table, the forgiving of the sinning traitor—it’s all here. The film is very faithful to the book—you could argue overly faithful (they are after all very different media). The cinematography is excellent—great use made of light and color, a refreshing change from the fashionable “dark” look that many directors afflict their work with, and also with the New Zealand locations. The special effects are great, and by that I mean they make the film look good and help the story along, rather than being just an end in themselves. Jim Broadbent is good as the professor and James McAvoy is VERY good as Mr. Tumnus. This is a family film, there’s no sex, nudity, or swearing. The violence (and there’s quite a lot of that in CS Lewis) is toned down so you don’t see any gratuitous blood and gore.
However, there are a lot of disadvantages. The rest of the acting is pretty awful. The child actors are mostly wooden. The white witch may be an ice queen but she is not the emotionless zombie that Tilda Swinton portrays. The beavers are just furry creatures whose expressions are too difficult to see. Aslan looks like a great lion, but he doesn’t look like the King of the Beasts and Liam Neeson lacks “gravitas” as his voice.
Secondly, the music is DIRE. The incidental music doesn’t help the moods of the film and the main theme is so bland I forgot it while I was hearing it.
Thirdly, the film is too long, it is too slow and it is too flat. There’s not enough explanation of what is going on and somehow, in some way, the wonder of the story dissipates. It becomes, frankly, boring. As well as the serious retelling of the gospel story in an alternate world, the Narnian Chronicles are meant to be FUN, but most of the comic elements of the story, the little touches that make you care about the characters and engage with the story, are just missing. If you’re a Narnia aficionado, this won’t matter too much, but if you’ve never read the stories, you won’t come away with a very good impression of them.
I’ve loved the Narnian chronicles ever since they were read to me at school and I had high hopes for this film. The Christian message is still there, but I’m afraid it hasn’t been well-packaged. It’s like listening to a bad sermon. The words are right, but the delivery isn’t. I guess that a bad film is just a bad film, irrespective of its “Christian” credentials.
Excellent! / 1½
However, there are a lot of disadvantages. The rest of the acting is pretty awful. The child actors are mostly wooden. The white witch may be an ice queen but she is not the emotionless zombie that Tilda Swinton portrays. The beavers are just furry creatures whose expressions are too difficult to see. Aslan looks like a great lion, but he doesn’t look like the King of the Beasts and Liam Neeson lacks “gravitas” as his voice.
Secondly, the music is DIRE. The incidental music doesn’t help the moods of the film and the main theme is so bland I forgot it while I was hearing it.
Thirdly, the film is too long, it is too slow and it is too flat. There’s not enough explanation of what is going on and somehow, in some way, the wonder of the story dissipates. It becomes, frankly, boring. As well as the serious retelling of the gospel story in an alternate world, the Narnian Chronicles are meant to be FUN, but most of the comic elements of the story, the little touches that make you care about the characters and engage with the story, are just missing. If you’re a Narnia aficionado, this won’t matter too much, but if you’ve never read the stories, you won’t come away with a very good impression of them.
I’ve loved the Narnian chronicles ever since they were read to me at school and I had high hopes for this film. The Christian message is still there, but I’m afraid it hasn’t been well-packaged. It’s like listening to a bad sermon. The words are right, but the delivery isn’t. I guess that a bad film is just a bad film, irrespective of its “Christian” credentials.
Excellent! / 1½
Martin Bourne, age 44
Comments from young people
Positive—This is called a “children’s story,” but that does NOT mean that adults will be bored! (In fact, I was on the edge of my seat for much of the time.) This movie was so good I hope they never have to remake it! I also hope they make the rest of the books into movies, too. It is very encouraging to see something so uplifting come into theatres when the likes of “Brokeback Mountain” are trying to get to us. …
Excellent! / 4½
Excellent! / 4½
Willow, age 16
Positive—This movie helped me to understand a little more of the immeasurable and unconditional Love of Christ. I cried during parts of the movie because I couldn’t help but think about how much Jesus had to suffer and go through so much shame for my sake, just like when Aslan sacrificed himself. My reaction after watching “The Chronicles of Narnia” was, “Thank You so much, God, for loving me as I am and accepting me as Your own. Thank You for already overcoming Satan and Death on the Cross.” I pray that by watching this movie, many people would come to accept Jesus as their personal Savior. He loves you so much that He gave His one and only Son, that if you only believe in Him, you will not perish but have eternal life.
Excellent! / 5
Excellent! / 5
Hannah, age 17
Positive—It can be said that C.S.Lewis would be proud by what the director Adam Anderson did with the first of the seven series chronicles. He reached into The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe with his camera and literally brought to life one of the most beloved classics of all time. Though it stands to be two hours and thirty minutes, I found myself carried far and fast into Narnia, leaving behind the theater seat completely. It’s an absolute feast for the spirit and the imagination. It is a testimony to those who will listen and a message to those who’s hearts are open.
My hopes for this movie is that it will override the witchery of Harry Potter and be an evangelistic tool to reach out to the world and guide people to see that there is more than fantasy to the chronicles that C.S. Lewis wrote. That there is etched in its words the Truth of Jesus Christ and the words from the mouth of God.
If ten was a rating, I’d rate it eleven. But five is the highest it will go. I recommend it to everyone.
Excellent! / 5
My hopes for this movie is that it will override the witchery of Harry Potter and be an evangelistic tool to reach out to the world and guide people to see that there is more than fantasy to the chronicles that C.S. Lewis wrote. That there is etched in its words the Truth of Jesus Christ and the words from the mouth of God.
If ten was a rating, I’d rate it eleven. But five is the highest it will go. I recommend it to everyone.
Excellent! / 5
The Writer, age 16
Positive—Wow! …incredibly breath-taking from the start to the end. Perfect actors and actresses for the roles. Mr. Taumnus, most delightful and fascinating faun, his character and wholesome friendship with Lucy draws the audience in and captivates. Gentle, always-trying-to be-reasonable Susan inspires. Rebellious, and slightly ornery Edmond pulls at your heart-strings when he stumbles yet is forgiven by his family, and brave-hearted Peter who is asked to grow up far sooner than a child should be, and Aslan, the gentle and forgiving lion who brings the whole movie together. All are intertwined into the story and bring out the focal points of the movie with their wonderful acting skills and realistic human faults.
The scenery and animals are all out-of-this world with their brilliance and beauty! The animals look so amazingly real that you can actually convince yourself that they are in that room with you! After this movie ended, I wanted to see it again and again. I recommend it to all who can and will watch. …It is worth the wait and money! I give it two thumbs up!! AMAZING!!
Excellent! / 5
The scenery and animals are all out-of-this world with their brilliance and beauty! The animals look so amazingly real that you can actually convince yourself that they are in that room with you! After this movie ended, I wanted to see it again and again. I recommend it to all who can and will watch. …It is worth the wait and money! I give it two thumbs up!! AMAZING!!
Excellent! / 5
Eva Olvera, age 17
Positive—This movie was amazing! I was worried that with the PG rating they would tame things down and make it too family friendly. I was afraid the story would lose it’s impact. No worries anymore! This movie is so perfect, I can’t imagine how to make it better. If you liked the books, go see this movie. I can’t wait to find out when they’re going to make another book in this series into a movie. However, long it takes, it will be worth the wait.
Good / 4½
Good / 4½
David Demeusy, age 17
Positive—I would just like to say to those of you planning to see “The Chronicles of Narnia”—SEE IT! I went to see it… with my dad, brother, friend, uncle, and grandma. Everyone there liked it. I have read the book a long time ago, but my friend who was more “into” the books (and my daddy) said it was faithful to the books. The costuming was well-done. The music was perfect for the scenes. The acting was good. …The lion (Aslan) was animated, and he looked VERY real. I think some of the animals were real, then some were animated. You could not tell the difference (at least I didn’t). I wouldn’t recommend this movie for little children who get scared easily. My little brother saw it, (he’s 6) but he is a big fan of battle scenes. (We watch a fair amount of historical battle movies.) But if your children are young and get scared easily, I wouldn’t suggest they see it. The witch’s “helpers” are rather grotesque looking, but you need to remember that they are portraying a fantasy world. There’s no swearing, no sexual innuendo either. Finally, a perfectly clean movie that you can watch without being afraid your children will start repeating phrases from it. (if you know what I mean…) I especially liked the many things that Aslan did and said that seemed like analogies of the Bible, and of what Christ did for us. Very good. …I’m very glad that the movie-makers didn’t cut it out or twist it.)… I highly recommend this movie!!
Excellent! / 4½
Excellent! / 4½
Stephanie, age 14
Positive—I LOVED this movie. My school got to see it one day before opening, and I LOVED it. It portrays exactly what Christ did for us. The lion is the symbol of Jesus, and it totally showed what God did for us. I was very very impressed. I truly think families should go see this movie. It had no bad language. Its kind of a mini Lord of the Rings without all the sick creatures. This movie touched me soo much. I seriously wanted to cry. It kind of reminded me of “The Passion of Christ”. I recommend this movie to all parents. My overall view is super excellent! Good Job Disney!
Excellent! / 5
Excellent! / 5
Sarah Jacobson, age 14
Positive—This movie was SOOOOOOOOO good! It’s very intense, and a great movie for anyone of any age to see. It was clear what the Christian message in the movie was, even to a non-Christian, yet it’s in a fascinating way that you want to watch. The characters were believable, and the computerized characters were so real! Excellent movie! Everyone should see it!!
Excellent! / 5
Excellent! / 5
Dee, age 16
Positive—I am a serious Narnia fan. I’ve read the series several times through, and my friends and I stayed up till midnight on the 8th to watch it on its first showing. I was not disappointed. The quality of filmmaking was excellent. The animals were very well done and the special effects were incredible. The acting was also well done, too.
The battles were intense, so younger children might be scared. Also the Witch’s creatures were creepy and grotesque—just the thing to give small kids nightmares. There were suspenseful parts and a few jump scenes, but they weren’t too bad.
I think the underlying message in this movie would only be clear if you had been told what it means. But once you do know, all the small but significant things that rely on the analogy are very prominent. I would definitely recommend this movie… There is nothing morally offensive (other than the usual “bad guy” stuff, but that is clearly portrayed as undesirable.) An incredible movie, both in quality and morally. A definite must-see.
Excellent! / 4½
The battles were intense, so younger children might be scared. Also the Witch’s creatures were creepy and grotesque—just the thing to give small kids nightmares. There were suspenseful parts and a few jump scenes, but they weren’t too bad.
I think the underlying message in this movie would only be clear if you had been told what it means. But once you do know, all the small but significant things that rely on the analogy are very prominent. I would definitely recommend this movie… There is nothing morally offensive (other than the usual “bad guy” stuff, but that is clearly portrayed as undesirable.) An incredible movie, both in quality and morally. A definite must-see.
Excellent! / 4½
Rachael, age 13
Positive—This is one of the best movies of the year!! I just loved how Aslan quoted Jesus during the entirety of the movie. The movie quality was absolutely incredible, the casting was great, and it had good Christian theology mixed in with it. I also give the director (Andrew Adamson) a big thumbs up for the way he directed it considering he just made “Shrek”. I give this movie an A++!!
Excellent! / 5
Excellent! / 5
Kurt, age 14
Positive—An excellent film! C.S. Lewis’ classic tale is portrayed accurately in the movie. I have never seen a movie so close to a book it was “based” upon! As with most films, two hours is not enough to give all of the background into the details of narnia like “deep” and “deeper” magic, which was not fully explained in the film. If Walden Media and the director decide to continue with the sequels, there should be ample opportunity to fill all the gaps. I feel this classic has something for everyone. Mr. and Mrs. Beaver have repartees that adults will pickup on, while children are entertained by the magic of the world in the wardrobe. An instant classic and favorite!
Good / 5
Good / 5
Ross, age 16
Positive—Everything in this movie was great! One of the best movies I have ever seen. It has some humor, action without gore, no vulgarity, no hint of sexual immorality,a good storyline without boredom, and good dialogue. C.S. Lewis’s Christian worldview shines right through as with the book. …The whole family will enjoy it. The entire church will enjoy this film!
Good / 5
Good / 5
Grant Brobson, age 13
Positive—The movie “Narnia” was everything I hoped it would be. It was AWESOME!! It was a bit scary for little kids, like the part at the stone table. It didn’t scare me because I have read all the books, and knew what to expect. Believe me, they didn’t change a thing! Please do not miss “Narnia.” It is the best movie I have ever seen!
Excellent! / 5
Excellent! / 5
Elizabeth, age 11
Positive—This, along with “Star Wars 3” was my absolute favorite movie this year! It was excellent. I felt that it pushed the PG rating as far as it can go with violence, but there was nothing else objectionable at all! The characters were very easy to warm up to and love. It was much too scary for young children, but everyone else should love it. I felt Liam Neeson’s voice gave the Aslan character a stern yet loving feel that made you fall in love with him. There were also some humorous lines that weren’t offensive or cheesy. They really made you laugh! If there was a rating better than positive than I would definitely give it to this movie. Go see it, but leave the young children at home.
Excellent! / 5
Excellent! / 5
Geno, age 15
Positive—First off I would like to say that this movie does in fact follow the book almost completely. I personally thought that it was better than LOTR. As for the allegory and such, I thought it was very well done, frankly you could almost compare parts of the movie to parts of the Bible, with a clear cut Satan and a clear cut Jesus. One reviewer stated that if you wanted to see a movie with a clearer allegorical aspect towards the Bible watch LOTR. I personally would disagree with this… In all honesty I couldn’t see nearly as much clear cut allegory to the Bible or the Christian walk as this movie. As a matter of fact, JRR Tolkein didn’t even like allegory; In his forward to the work Tolkien expressed his dislike of allegory: “As for any inner meaning or ‘message,’ it has in the intention of the author none. It is neither allegorical nor topical” Don’t get me wrong, I know he was a strong Christian man and loved God with all of his heart, but maybe he wasn’t actually trying to put allegorical meaning into his stories the way Lewis did. Any movie can be taken and given allegory from an outside source, takes Star Wars for example: good side, bad side—many people thought it was a reference to the Christian life; we know this isn’t the case. This particular movie, however was not dulled down, Aslan lays down his life for someone that doesn’t deserve it, and defeats death and devil…
Good / 5
Good / 5
Daniel Robison, age 17
Positive—I’m a long-time fan of Narnia and have read all the books. My friend and I waited in line for an hour to get good seats (we were excited) and weren’t disappointed. Of course, no movie is better than the books, but this one followed the book very closely. …
Better than Average / 5
Better than Average / 5
Brittney, age 15
Neutral—…I also think they could have made it focus more on Aslan. Because there is a lot more meaning in him, because he represents Jesus. I have read the books over and over and they have a great message that people need to hear.
Good / 5
Good / 5
Elisabeth. G. Childress, age 14
Positive—…When my friends and I saw the movie they were interested about my beliefs. The movie is absolutely wonderful. …
Excellent! / 4½
Excellent! / 4½
Autumn, age 12
I would caution parents to think about how sensitive your child would be toward battle scenes and things that go along with that. The battle scenes are reminiscent of what is found in the Lord of the Rings movies, but in Narnia they are not as graphic, nor do they exhibit the blood and gore of the former. In the scene where Aslan is being killed, some of the witch’s creatures might be a little scary looking for younger children.
Overall, the creators of this film did a good job trying to keep the story true to the book. Due to the aforementioned, I would recommend this film to families with children 8 years old and up. I brought my sons 6 and 8 years old to view it. They loved it. I think that boys will enjoy this film more than girls.
My Ratings: Good / 5