Doom IIIReviewed By: Dan Harrison
VOLUNTEER GUEST REVIEWER
Gameplay: Id has been long known for poor, weak, and just plain horrible story lines. Quake and Doom have been associated with "kill big guy, find red key, find red door .etc". So id sought to disprove this by almost totally focusing on the single player game of Doom III. And after a better part of a decade to complete, and an all new engine to boot Doom III hits a sour note. The story is still the same story as the original Doom only retold. The game is very similar to id style only now after years since the first it only becomes dumber. Almost everything is scripted in the game and almost every room is the same thing. Go past a certain point and two guys pop in front of you and a guy appears from a doorway in the wall behind you. You would think that this was only a couple times, but this set of sequences reoccurs the entire game.
As you can see from the screenshots above, darkness is an understatement in this game. Where you're using your flashlight almost exclusively in every room before the repetitive formula happens again and again. One thing I did notice is that in Doom III the pentagrams seemed to be toned down quite a lot since Doom and Doom II. The pentagrams were more of a lighting affect on the floor and thus couldn't be seen quite as much. There is no question this is the most evil game I have ever played and I feel incredibly slimed after playing through the game. The main enemy is constantly telling you every half hour that "your soul is mine". The later levels are by far the worst with upside down crosses with people nailed to them you can't get much worse. Dimly lit candles that surround a sacrifice are the norm towards the end of the game. You just wonder if these are things that id actually sat there for over five years creating you can really understand how much of an influence the satanic cult has been on that organization. Not only the Doom series but Quake as well id has been know for creating the most satanic games of any company. Also too this game is very gory. This would definitely be in the extreme category and I could honestly make the claim that this game is no where near the mature rating of 17+ that it has been given, this is strictly an adult game. I really don't see any valuable aspect in playing this game, it's not fun. It literally eats away at you spiritually and really sucks you dry. Most games have some sort of multiplayer aspect that is incredibly appealing, but Doom III has almost nothing in that category with capping the players to server to only four you can't have much fun. After you beat the game there really is no replay value since it's the same monotonous formula over again.
Graphics: The graphics were simply unheard of two years ago, but now they just don't seem quite as impressive. Don't get me wrong the game is really beautiful graphically speaking, but there are many things that are seen that could have looked better. As you can see from the screenshot below the face is largely detailed, but the legs are really poor. If you look at its left leg you can see the transition from the leg to the foot is just not there, it's just a block. My point is clear graphics are great but would have looked a lot better if this game came out a year earlier. Some would argue that the video card industry would not have been able to keep the necessary frame rates up to play the game, but that is just not true. My video card is a Geforce 4 ti4200 and the game runs perfect.
Sound: In my opinion this is where Doom III shines. The game is completely done in 5.1 surround sound, and for those that can't afford system like that for your computer you're just not getting the full affect this game can give. I've played this game with both standard speakers and a set of 5.1 speakers and the difference is as clear as day. You can hear things crawling behind you, noises, shrieks, and cries all around. It's down right disturbing. From time to time you get the very scary “over here” sound from someone and when you look no one is there. Other times, like when you're in hell, you here constant screaming and babies crying. After an hour straight of this and the lights being off I can honestly say I was freaked out. This is what Doom III sought to bring, a completely horrific and terrifying game and that it has accomplished.
Christian Rating: There hasn't been a game that I would more than happily throw away after I just purchased it for fifty-five dollars than this one. The graphics are superb and sound is just down right awesome, but nothing will make up for the complete satanic feel and exposure this game will bring. As a twenty-one year old I have to say I was freaked out, disturbed, and horrified by Doom III's content. I can't imagine what a thirteen year old would feel like. After hours of exposure to this game, I could see a child's attitude and personality change because of this game. I would have displayed more images but due to the graphic and satanic nature of this game I just couldn't show it. Stay far away from Doom III it has no value to it at all. I would highly recommend that anyone who professes themselves to be Christians, to NOT PLAY THIS GAME.
Conclusion: Rating: 0 out of 5 due to high levels of occult images and sounds, massive gore, and terrifying exposure to hell and demons. No game has gone so far as Doom III.
No more comments are needed for this game.Negative—Heh. I'm suprised I am actually taking this stance on games like these, an attitude I would have spurned years ago. But there is no real way around it. Doom III is very satanic. One defense is that its a “good VS evil” struggle, that it actually sends a positve message about how Evil satan is. It does, indeed show evil in this game, but you don't really see any good. The “good” in this game is a marine armed to the teeth with a bunch of guns. Is that our defense against satan, for us to try to defeat him on our own power? Besides, even if you rationalize the occultic overtones, this game has an extreme level of violence. Just stay away from this game. My Ratings: [1/4]
—Eric LeCarde, age 21
Negative—I agree with you on all of your points. For those of you who want a good FPS just wait for Halo 2 or Half-Life 2. And in all good sense just go get an N64 and play Goldeneye or Shadows of the Empi My Ratings: [1 / 3]
Neutral—I see no evidence of any satanic cult influence on ID's employees. Simply using geometric symbols like a star inside a circle or a cross where the horizontal portion is below the vertical line's midsection doesn't strike me as a satanic plot any more than seeing a rainbow suggests a meteorological conspiracy to endorse sodomy. That some deviant groups through the years have attempted to appropriate innocuous symbols for their own uses doesn't mean that we Christians should acknowledge and grant them that conceptual seizure. Fashions and fads form and fade, but God remains the same today, yesterday, and forever, and his Word will not pass away. The game's grotesque monsters and environment, against which the player fights, I should add, could serve as a faint echo of the real and eternal horror that awaits anyone unwashed by the blood of Jesus Christ, and for that reason primarily (as it provides a platform on which one could share what Scripture says about hell) would I
recommend it to everyone. My Ratings: [3 / 3]
This review is a little late, but I ran into this thru a modding website where a thread was created to discuss this site's official review.
Now for my opinion. I think that the game is a technological and artistic wonder. It is a straight forward first person shooter. There is nothing new or exiciting in the gameplay with the exception of the flashlight and dynamic lights.
You can only either use a flashlight or a weapon at any time and when you are in a dark place, which is frequent, this makes for very immersive and therefore very intense gameplay. In fact, this is one of the most immersive games ever. This is why it is also one of the scariest and most disturbing games ever.
This game with scare you. It will make you feel creeped out. It isn't called Doom for no reason. It's supposed to give you the feeling of doom and you are supposed to rise above that feeling and fight back in the face of terror. That's the primary point of the game play and story.
There is a lot of satanic references since of course this game is about hell being unleased on human kind thru a dimensional portal on Mars. There has been quite a bit of talk about whether the inclusion of satanic references is an indication that the game is itself purposed to be satanic. One clearly missed detail in both sides of the discussion has been the, to me, obvious fact that the 'satanic' creatures are actually aliens and that they have been understood by humankind to be something religious.
This game doesn't take the stance that satan is real. It is like the movie Stargate and it takes what the creators of the game consider popular mythology and says that in the game world that the myth is real but not what humanity thinks, rather that hell is another dimesion of sadistic evil creatures that want to kill everything.
I am actually pretty suprised that nobody has brought this up in discussions about the game. Oh well, it's just a game.
Having said that… do I think that this game is appropriate for play. Well, it scared the hell out of me and I quit playing. I personally don't like the be terrified. Not for religious or moral reason, I just don't like the way it feels and to be honest, I don't understand those people who do. But, I can't honestly say that this game is evil or even intended to be evil. It is a haunted house. That's it. If this game had been made by Christians and the main character were an angel or a Christian who quoted scripture to fend off the demons then it wouldn't be considered evil, just bad taste. Which, as is, bad taste is what I consider Doom 3 to be.
Now. I am playing Quake 4. Doom 3 tech and art without the terror. I am not killing humans. I am not assaulting prosititutes. I am fighting for the survival of the human race from an alien invasion that wants to destroy humanity. Now, that's my kind of game.Although, give me a stealth game like Splinter Cell and NOW we're talking!! :) My Ratings: [3 / 4]
— Anton Bursch, age 31
Neutral—It is hard to take a positive stance on this game, because, as a lover of gory, FPS's Doom is an incredible game. But, the game is full of occult refrences, which was particularly disturbing to me. The gore is fairly realsitic, the violence is heavy, and the language is minimal. The game can become fairly repetitive, alot of the rooms look the same, but suprises are always around the corner. The game will always be startliing, even if it is something that you have already played through. The game itself is incredible, but the occult refrences in it drag it down and make it hard to recomend. My Ratings: [1 / 5]
Negative—Terrible tons of gore and images that are very freaky! Tons of occult! I dispise this game! I shot a “zombie” or something and it exploded into body parts! Sickest thing I ever played! My Ratings: [1 / 2]
Negative—I was extremely excited about this game. I'm a fan of the first 2 Doom games. But when I actually got around to playing it, it wasn't all cracked up to what I thought it would be. There's alot of gore in this one, there's demonic images, magic, and demons. And it is just to unenjoyable, not to mention the flashlight issue. And if you must play something like this, then play Resident Evil 4. KEEP AWAY FROM DOOM 3!! My Ratings: [1 / 3]
Negative—I agree with you on all of your points. For those of you who want a good FPS just wait for Halo 2 or Half-Life 2. And in all good sense just go get an N64 and play Goldeneye or Shadows of the Empire. My Ratings: [1 / 3]
Positive—Personnally I found this game entertaining to play. Granted my machine is not as high spec as it could be, and as such, the game drops me to my desktop everynow and then, but that is an acceptable loss. I will admit I am not Christian, but my faith mirrors christianity in many ways.
I will freely admit that the game is intended for adults, the 18 label makes that clear, if your kids are playing this, then the fault is yours, not the game designers. There is a lot of satianic images and iconography in this game, but that is to be expected given that the main character, is fighting AGAINST the forces of hell. A champion of humanity fighting against the forces of darkness, condemming all that is evil. This game clearly shows that this kind of icongraphy is evil, with enemies spawning from the symbols the player learns to fear and avoid them. The game also indicates mans over reliance on technology, with the teleporter experiments being the catalyst for this incident. While multiplayer is lacking this is excusable.So in summary, the game has a massive amount of violence, there is a lot of anti-christian imagery in it. But you must remember, that this game is about fighting against the forces of Hell. At no point does the game condone or support the deamons. My Ratings: [3 / 4]
—Andy, age 19
Positive— I believe that Doom III gives you a sense of horror. You are a human stuck in Hell's apocalypse. I see this game as a tool to make fun of Satan himself. You are destroying Hell, you're not worshiping it. I don't see anything wrong in this game. Of course, children will get scared because they do not understand, but teenage kids will learn the difference between Good and Evil, God and Satan, Hell and Heaven, and they will learn that good always succeeds. When will you people learn that most games are about Good vs. Evil and Good always succeeding. My Ratings: [3 / NR]
Negative—This is the most bloody game I've ever seen anybody play. And in addition to that, the game revolves around demons breaking out of hell and killing people on a space station. There is way too much gore in this, and things like making corpses explode and sending bloody guts fly into the air is totally unneccesary. This game is over-rated and not right for a christian to be playing. My Ratings: [1 / 5]
Negative—I have to totally agree that this game was repetitive and it did contain all the elements described by the reviewer. However, I did find the game thrilling until the repetitive content began which is why I give it a negative. I think sometimes as Christians, we forget that we are battling against such evil (demons and the forces of hell) and this game engulfs you in a situation where you can do so, albeit in an extremely horrible and disturbing environment.
I think it is somewhat premature to say that ID is engulfed in satanism, just because the game shows that content. There are also many cults showing 'Christian' imagerary that are yet however, more satanic than this game. If it is promoting satanism, that is one thing, but again, it is apparent that your character is fighting against it. The goal here is to destroy demons, not to act or join as one. The Grand Theft auto series is far more offensive than this game.
Finally, I must agree that this game is for mature adults only, and should be passed by those who may be even somewhat offended or disturbed by the images described, or even may offend another by playing it. One should absolutely pray and use the Lord's judgment if considering this game. My Ratings: [2 / 3]
Positive—I think I have to disagree with the reviewer's words here. While this is definitely something I wouldn't want a kid to play due to its ultraviolent content, I think you're forgetting the fact that in Doom 3, the forces of Hell are the bad guys, not even remotely depicted as the good guys. You play a Space Marine who's buddies have all just been killed by demons, and then you go on a quest to lay down the smack on the Hell itself with a big silly gun. If that isn't a positive, black and white message of “Good beats up Evil” I don't know what is. The Satanism shown in Doom 3 is cast in an entirely villainous light, and is never glorified or presented in a way that would suggest it's a good thing at all, which I think is perfectly fine. Yes, it's horrendously violent, dark, and scary, but that's what evil really is! I would rather play a game like Doom 3 that pushes the edge and shows the demonic badguys as they really are rather than give us a weak, watered down version out of
fear of stepping on over
But I do agree that Doom 3 has an extremely weak storyline and just felt like a bad horror movie. Honestly it seems like they intentionally tried to make it really lame, maybe to make it seem like a B-rated horror flick. The key to enjoying this game is to get into it expecting little more than a haunted house ride and some campy scripting. That, and the gameplay just felt way too scripted and nowhere near as real as, say, Half-Life 2. My Ratings: [4 / 3]
Negative—I have played the game and I think that it is a very scary game. It has a lot of demonic and satanic stuff in it. You see during game play zombies eatin a human and the human alive and screeming. You see pentograms and upside down crosses. I WOULD RECCOMEND THAT NOBODY GET THIS GAME. The game is very offensive to christians so do not get it. My Ratings: [1 / 3]
Negative—I agree with everything said here. And I almost feel sorry for Id software, there they were with this amazing new graphics technology and the oppurtunity to create a good, solid, revolutionary first-person shooter. But they threw this chance away by loading the game up with satanic imagery, demonic acts, and things that just shouldn't be seen.
That said, I kept the game, but I refuse to even touch the singleplayer game, one playthrough was one too many. You see, the actual engine the game runs on is a good one, if it weren't for all the excessive gore, violence, and demonic imagery, this game would be great. So I kept the game for the editor, which I use to create levels and maps which I find fun to play, and which of course have absolutely nothing to do with the main game's abundant evil. If you're going to buy this game, buy it for the flexibility the engine gives you to create your own game experience, and not for the horrible single-player. My Ratings: [1 / 4]
Disclaimer: The opinions expressed in this Christian Spotlight review are those of the reviewer (both ratings and recommendations), and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of Films for Christ or the Christian Answers Network.
Review supplied by Christian Spotlight Guide2Games, a ministry of Christian Answers. Copyright © Films for Christ. Spotlight's URL: http://ChristianSpotlight.com • Mailing address: PO Box 1167, Marysville WA 98270-1167, USA • “Christian Spotlight’s Guide to Games” and “Guide2Games” are service marks of Films for Christ.