Reviewed by: Carole McDonnell
|Featuring:||Mekhi Phifer, Josh Hartnett, Julia Stiles, Martin Sheen, Rain Phoenix|
|Director:||Tim Blake Nelson|
|Producer:||Eric Gitter, Anthony Rhulen, Dan Fried|
|Distributor:||Lions Gate Films|
The tragedies of Shakespeare, however great they might be, don’t always ring true. Perhaps, we are too removed from the play’s period to comprehend the full scope of a tragedy. Rarely do we truly feel the fear or empathy. However, in “O” we do. Aristotle wrote that a real tragedy evokes a catharsis. He defined a catharsis as a combination of empathy and fear. We sympathize with the characters and are afraid because we could see ourselves or someone we know in their predicament. This is one of the best films of the summer and like “A.I.”, it is a philosophical tearjerker. We want to cry because the world is sometimes such a terrible place.
The film “O” is based on Shakespeare’s tragedy, “Othello”. But whereas Shakespeare’s “Othello” was a war story set in Venice, “O” is set in an academic setting. In “O”, Odin James (Meki Phifer) is a champion high school basketball player, beloved by the beautiful and popular Desi (Julia Stiles) and best friend—he thinks—of Hugo (Josh Hartnett.) The transfer to the high school setting works admirably for modern day audiences. Where else would hormonal rage, jealousy and social hierarchy work to create such a tragedy? In Shakespeare’s play, the villainous Iago admits he doesn’t quite know why he dislikes Othello. In one scene he says rumors are around that Othello cuckolded him. In another, he mentions his jealousy. It is possible that Iago was racist. After all, Shakespeare, also wrote that great speech against anti-semitism in “The Merchant of Venice”. But, in Elizabethan times, was there a word for the kind of hatred, jealousy, discomfort and fear that we all have come to call racism?
Jealousy and racism share a common trait. They are pumped up by a perverse sense of righteous indignation. We feel something has been taken from us and we feel a dislike for something we perceive as unfair. Both the jealous and the racist believe that life has wrongly given something to someone else. The question is: does the jealousy and fear come before the racism or do all these evils arrive hand in hand? On the whole, racists and jealous persons do a great deal of hating. Their actions might be a smoldering hateful look which may or may not hurt its recipient. But that’s about all. In Hugo’s case, his jealousy spurs him to action. Hugo yields to temptation, and not just to an angry look. Hugo is methodical, subtle, and downright sneaky.
In Shakespeare’s play—and in this film—everyone has lost something. The characters want honor, respect, daughter, father, lover. Everyone is concerned with losing something/someone and wanting it back. Only Hugo, however, does something about it. In this adaptation, Hugo is jealous of Odin James (O.J.?) because of his dad’s attentions. We dislike Hugo’s plotting and scheming and yet—like many of the high school shooters of the recent years—he is not someone the audience truly dislikes. We keep feeling that if only his dad, Duke (Martin Sheen), the win-oriented coach, would honor, respect and cherish the kid just a little bit more, then the tragedy would be averted. But that is not to be. Hugo has lost his bearings and it is a trifle too late for any attentions from Duke to bring him back.
Perhaps kings and princes and warrior-soldiers are too above us for us to truly relate to their quandaries. After all, who can understand the grievance of a seminarian prince whose mother has married his uncle? Without a belief in the divine right of kings, the precepts in Leviticus against marrying one’s brother’s wife, the back history of a king who did just that and regretted it …and a belief that demons walk the hurt with the intent to deceive innocent God-fearing people, “Hamlet” is merely the story of another confused angry person. The tragedy of school killings like the one at Columbine High School, raging youthful testosterone, the history of American and European racism and the cruel hierarchy of high school all have contributed to a tragic and relevant updating of “Othello”. Anyone who remembers sitting on the sidelines while other people were honored will feel for the villain Hugo. Anyone who knows that teenagers are ruled by their hormones will understand how a tragedy could happen. The film is wonderfully real. The language is offensive (Kids-in-Mind report 61 F-words… 4 religious profanities, 3 religious exclamations), but it is also real. Unfortunately, this is how most teenagers, white or black, speak.
Christians will understand the nature of temptation and man’s attempt to set matters right by doing the wrong thing. Christian parents will understand how dangerous those teenage years truly are. There are sex scenes (of course) including an interracial couple. it’s sex outside of marriage that’s wrong here, not the racial mix (see our “Racial Issues” section). The screenwriter, Brad Kaaya is not a known name. After this film he will definitely be known. Technically, this is one of the best films of the summer and one of the better Shakespearean adaptations. But be cautious—there is plenty of potentially offensive content.