If Christ’s miracles really happened, why weren’t they reported by historians?

A skeptic asks: “The Bible makes a lot of claims about Jesus' miraculous feats. But if all these amazing things really did happen, why didn't reputable contemporary historians write about them? You'd think that phenomenon like a great darkness at Noon (crucifixion), or bright stars moving across the sky toward Bethlehem (Christmas), would have been reported by other historians. Yet we only have the biased claims of Christ's supporters.”

The reporting of the events around the life and death of Jesus are just about what you would expect in the first century, given that Jesus' following was so small during his lifetime, that He lived in such a remote corner of the Roman Empire, and given the state of astronomy at that time.

Despite these limitations, Josephus (the first century Jewish historian), and Tacitus (an early second century Roman historian) make significant reference to Him. And actually, the very thing that you call for does exist. The mid-first century Roman historian Thallus makes reference to the darkness of the sun at the time of the crucifixion as he tries to refute the apostles’ claim. He argues that the crucifixion had, by chance, taken place during a solar eclipse.

Your position discounts the experience and witness of those who were “biased”—presumably referring to the New Testament writers, biased because they believed in Jesus. But who was unbiased? Can we count on those who rejected Jesus to have been unbiased? Why? Those closest to the events had high stakes in trying to protect their power base. The reports of Jesus' followers [actually] gain a certain authority because of their willingness to die for their witness to the resurrection.

More information on-line

  • Miracles (our WebBible Encyclopedia)

  • Has science disproved the miracles associated with Jesus Christ? Answer

  • “Miracles are not possible,” some claim. Is this true? Answer

  • What was the Star of Bethlehem? Answer

  • Does the New Testament provide a reliable history of Christ's life? Answer

  • INFALLIBILITY - How can the Bible be infallible if it is written by fallible humans? Answer

  • Inspiration of Scripture by God

  • When we say that the Bible is the Word of God, does that imply that it is completely accurate, or does it contain insignificant inaccuracies in details of history and science? Answer

  • What about those CONTRADICTIONS in the Bible that I have heard about? Answer

  • INTERNAL HARMONY - A skeptic questions whether the Bible's internal harmony is evidence of its Divine inspiration - He suggests that the existence of the James Bond film series disproves that argument. See our response

  • How can I know the Bible is TRUE? Answer

  • What is the Bible?

  • Questions for Skeptics

  • Discover the HOPE that Jesus Christ provides - GO

  • Learn God's Story: From Creation to Eternity - GO

  • Is Jesus Christ the answer? GO

  • With so many denominations and religions, how can I decide which are true and which are false? Answer

  • Judging from all the hypocrisy in the church, why would I want to be a Christian? Answer

Author: Richard B. Keyes. Text supplied by AIIA Institute.

Richard Keyes is Director of L'Abri MA, a residential study center in Southborough, Massachusetts. L'Abri was founded in Switzerland by the late Dr. Francis Schaeffer in 1955. Mr. Keyes is also and author and lecturer. Since 1997 he has served as an AIIA Resource Associate (worldviews).

Text Copyright © 2002, 2004, AIIA Institute, All Rights Reserved—except as noted on attached “Usage and Copyright” page that grants ChristianAnswers.Net users generous rights for putting this page to work in their homes, personal witnessing, churches and schools.

Visit AIIA Institute's Web site

Christian Answers EffectiveEvangelism™ site - Learn how to be more effective in sharing the Gospel If you are a follower of Jesus Christ who is interested in sharing your faith with skeptics, including agnostics and atheists, please visit our page about Atheism in our EffectiveEvangelism.com site.

Christian Answers Network
PO Box 1167
Marysville WA 98270-1167         Submit your Questions

Jesus Christ: His Identity, Life, Death & Resurrection Christian Answers home page
home page
Christian Answers Network HOMEPAGE and DIRECTORY