Reviewed by: Charity Bishop
The sin of physical and mental abuse of children
Differences and similarities between fantasy magic and real witchcraft and sorcery
Sorcery in the Bible
Witches in the Bible
|Featuring:|| Eddie Redmayne … Newt Scamander
Ezra Miller … Credence
Colin Farrell … Percival Graves
Zoë Kravitz …
Ron Perlman … Gnarlack
Katherine Waterston … Porpentina Goldstein
Jon Voight … Henry Shaw, Sr
Dan Fogler … Jacob Kowalski
Carmen Ejogo … Seraphina Picquery
Christine Marzano … Exterminator
Alison Sudol … Queenie Goldstein
Samantha Morton … Mary Lou
Gemma Chan …
See all »
|Director:||David Yates—“Harry Potter…” franchise|
See all »
|Distributor:||Warner Bros. Pictures|
Sequel: “Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes of Grindelwald” (2018)
One of the most talented and controversial (among believers) authors of the last decade, J.K. Rowling never fails to cast a spell over her audience—and the box office. The global phenomenon of the boy wizard and his friends left no family untouched, creating fans and critics alike. Now, she launches into a new franchise depicting the adventures of Newt Scamander, known in the Potterverse as the author of a book on Hogwarts’ “required reading” list.
New York City, 1926.
Jacob Kowalski (Dan Fogler) doesn’t know magic, wizards, or magical creatures exist. He works in a cannery and dreams of owning a bakery. Dressed up, with a suitcase full of pastries, he enters the bank to apply for a loan… but Newt (Eddie Redmayne) plops down beside him. When Newt dashes off in pursuit of an escaped magical creature from his case of fantastic beasts, he leaves an egg behind. It hatches—launching Jacob into a mythological world where pretty girls bake dinner in midair before his eyes, suitcases are much bigger on the inside, goblins run nightclubs, and where the ugly truth of the unseen horror wreaking havoc on New York comes to light.
Newt is on a world tour, intent on doing research for a book. Alas, his escaped creatures inside the bank lands him a one way ticket to “the authorities.” The auror who arrests him is Tina (Katherine Waterston), whose recent behavior earned her banishment to the basement and suspension from her duties. She hopes this capture will put her back in the good graces of the higher-ups. It doesn’t. Then, they realize Jacob has Newt’s briefcase. And he’s just popped the locks.
Several things kept circling through my mind while watching this film. The first is what Jesus said, “Better for them to be thrown into the sea with a millstone tied around their neck than to cause one of these little ones to stumble.” “Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them” is many things, but at its heart, is a story about child abuse. It’s about losing oneself in the pain of suffering and the devastation of the soul. It’s about turning pain into uncontrolled anger, and lost innocence. It’s about injustice, cruelty, and redemption. Rowling has tackled these topics before, but never with such raw depth. This is a more mature world than Harry Potter. Abuse no longer is sleeping in a cupboard; it’s red welts, lowered heads, and fear behind children’s eyes as they remove their belt and hand it to “mother.” Scenes where an abused young man is emotionally manipulated by Graves (Colin Farrell) are equally difficult to watch. He offers love to a boy desperate for any sign of human kindness, only to tear it away when he doesn’t get what he wants.
Newt and Graves represent the forces of good and evil within the story. Newt is the savior, who loves all creatures and tries to save the lost. Graves is the devil who manipulates, twists the pain deeper, and turns his back on suffering. Though prevalent, these scenes doesn’t overwhelm the story; they’re part of a larger narrative scope, which shifts between comedic beats, delightful explorations into new places and creatures, and an underlining mystery. Entertaining, engaging, and memorable, it’s an assault on those who inflict harm, an exploration of the pain it causes, and an appeal to the audience to care about “the least of these.”
Rowling tucks many delightful winks into the story for long-time fans of the books; names such as Dumbledore and Grindelwald surface, along with a subtle reference to the search for the Deathly Hallows. We meet Bowtruckles and other beasts. The film is gorgeous, an immersive experience, from swinging Twenties streets to the lovely costume design. There’s little profanity or sensuality (Queenie greets them in a slip, and sensually clothes herself; she says most men “think” about her in the way Jacob does, once they meet; Newt says a creature must “mate” and attracts her back into the briefcase with a scent that reminds her of a male of her kind). Violence includes creatures wreaking havoc. Wizards duel one another intending harm. Physical abuse is implied with a boy removing his belt and handing it to his “mother” several times; he and other children show welts on their hands. A magical force carries people up in the air and drops them from great heights, killing them.
No doubt you’ve already reached a conclusion about whether the magic in Rowling’s stories is appropriate for your family. This film contains much of the established fantasy magic from the earlier franchise (vanishing and appearing in different places, modifying memories to erase magical events, wand-waving, etc.) and emphasizes one character’s ability to read others’ minds. Small children may find some scenes (particularly the idea of an abusive parent) frightening.
Some may see the character of Mary Lou as a blow at fundamentalism, perhaps even an embodiment of the religious right (in a time when debate rages over sexual orientation, Mary Lou forcing her “children” to repress their “true nature” brings up parallels for discussion), but I see her as the personification of all that is not godly. Jesus spoke out against abuse, and offered love free of manipulation. Like Newt, he seeks to pull broken, hurting people back from their own inner darkness.
The question is whether people will accept it.
Violence: Moderate to heavy—some scary for young ones / Profanity: Minor—“h*ll” (3), “b*gger” (2), “jeez” (1) / Sex/Nudity: Mild
See list of Relevant Issues—questions-and-answers.