Reviewed by: Jonathan Rodriguez
CONTRIBUTOR
Moral Rating: | Very Offensive |
Moviemaking Quality: |
|
Primary Audience: | Teens Adults |
Genre: | Sci-Fi Action Adventure |
Length: | 1 hr. 57 min. |
Year of Release: | 2005 |
USA Release: |
June 29, 2005 (wide) |
Extraterrestrials—Are we alone, or is there lots of life elsewhere in the universe? Answer
Bible and ETs—What does the Bible say about intelligent life on other planets? Answer
Does Scripture refer to life in space? Answer
What is Secular Humanism? Answer
Every time you buy a movie ticket or rent a video you are casting a vote telling Hollywood “That’s what I want.” Why does Hollywood continue to promote immoral programming? Are YOU part of the problem?
Violence in the media—how does it affect people? Answer
Featuring | Tom Cruise, Dakota Fanning, Tim Robbins, Justin Chatwin, Columbus Short, Morgan Freeman, Amy Ryan, See all » |
Director |
Steven Spielberg |
Producer | Paramount Pictures, DreamWorks SKG, See all » |
Distributor |
I have never seen the original 1953 version of “War of the Worlds,” H.G. Wells’ alien-invasion classic, so I cannot compare Steven Spieberg’s 2005 remake. I can compare it to some of the more recent alien-invasion flicks, movies like “Independance Day,” “The X-Files Movie,” or even “Mars Attacks.” What I like best about the new “War of the Worlds” as opposed to the other films mentioned is that “War” is firmly rooted in everyday life. We don’t see politicians fight over how to handle the aliens, or military generals arguing over strategic plans of action. We see an everyday fellow in Ray Ferrier (Tom Cruise) basically running for his life, trying to protect his kids and trying not to get zapped by the alien death ray.
“War” opens in what looks like New Jersey, where Ray is arriving home to meet his children Robbie and Rachel, who are staying with their bum of a dad while their mom and her new husband visit Boston. The kids don’t care much for Ray, and it appears that the feeling may be mutual after Ray calls his son an “a**hole.” The friendly family bonding is interrupted when a very strange, intense lightning storm hits outside. When it is over, Ray heads out into the streets, where the rest of the people in the neighborhood have gathered to look at a spot that seems to have been struck by lightning numerous times.
Before long, the ground begins to rumble and crack, buildings topple over, and slowly something begins to rise out of the ground. It is a huge metallic robot, that serves as a vehicle for the alien attackers. At first, the townspeople stare at it in wonder, but then begin running for their lives as the pod fires on the people and buildings. Ray runs home to find his children, and they head towards Boston, where it seems Ray wants to get his kids to their mother so he won’t have to worry about them anymore.
They find what appears to be the only working vehicle in the county (the lightning storm caused everything to stop working: cars, watches, lights, cell phones… but apparently not a video camera). Ray and kids drive past throngs of helpless people, hoping to avoid the alien assault that is now affecting the whole world.
The content of “War of the Worlds” will be enough to keep younger children and easily frightened teenagers away. The film contains some very intense, at times distubing, scenes of people being zapped to death by the aliens, shot, chased, and abducted. There is some violence and blood, and a rather disturbing killing, that we don’t see but understand it happened. I felt terrible for a boy of about 9 in the row in front of me. It was clearly disturbing to him, and he had his head turned back on his father’s shoulder toward me for most of the film. The film also contains language, frequent uses of the Lord’s name in vain, and other commonly used (in films) profanity.
What I have come to appreciate most about Steven Spielberg’s films is the sense of wonder and awe they fill me with. Nothing can describe how I felt when I first saw the dinosaurs in “Jurassic Park” and most of his films have some new, exciting element that sets them apart from films made by less accomplished directors. But, that feeling is missing from “War of the Worlds.” The movie may just as well have been directed by the guy next door, and in that case, I probably wouldn’t have bothered seeing it.
There are holes in the film, scenes that don’t feel like they belong, and an ending that feels forced rather than natural. I must admit, the ending has about as much validity as say, all of “Sahara,” but without the laughs. When it finally did end, “War of the Worlds” added up to a huge disappointment, more along the lines of “The Lost World: Jurassic Park” than say “Minority Report.”
If angry aliens aren’t your thing anyway, rent “E.T.” And if they are, well I am sure there are better films out there to rent that have to do with hostile foreign visitors. “Mars Attacks” anyone?
Violence: Heavy / Profanity: Heavy / Sex/nudity: None
Bible and ETs—What does the Bible say about intelligent life on other planets? Answer
See list of Relevant Issues—questions-and-answers.
First, from a Christian point of view, there is nothing to recommend. The human relationships are lacking depth. No one shows any spiritual qualities of any kind. There is little kindness, caring or compassion among the individuals in the film. People are shot and beaten for the use of a car. Others are pushed off a boat. Few are shown coming to their aid. No one is seen praying or turning to God for help. Other commenters here have correctly covered the relationship of Tom Cruise’s chraracter with his family.
There is much use of God’s name in vain—which I did not expect as the PG-13 listing did not include language. If I had known this was the case, I would not have attended. There was an incredible amount of violence to the point of horror. In a scene near the end the blood of devoured human beings was shown spewed all over the place. Also, a graphic scene of an alien ingesting human beings.
The film is noisy, dark and HUMANISTIC to the core. And the ending—a total letdown. I cannot recommend it to anyone. And it should have an R rating, not PG-13!
My Ratings: Offensive/3½