Today’s Prayer Focus
Copyright, Warner Bros. Pictures

The Water Diviner

also known as “A Promessa de Uma Vida,” “Promessas de Guerra,” See more »
MPA Rating: R-Rating (MPA) for war violence including some disturbing images.

Reviewed by: Jeremy Landes

Moral Rating: Offensive
Moviemaking Quality:
Primary Audience: Adults
Genre: War Drama
Length: 1 hr. 51 min.
Year of Release: 2014
USA Release: April 24, 2015 (limited—300+)
DVD: July 28, 2015
Copyright, Warner Bros. Picturesclick photos to ENLARGE Copyright, Warner Bros. Pictures Copyright, Warner Bros. Pictures Copyright, Warner Bros. Pictures Copyright, Warner Bros. Pictures Copyright, Warner Bros. Pictures Copyright, Warner Bros. Pictures Copyright, Warner Bros. Pictures
Relevant Issues

About war in the Bible

What is the Biblical perspective on war? Answer

Copyright, Warner Bros. Pictures

Gallipoli Campaign—devastating battle of Gallipoli in Turkey during World War I

ignorned by the film is the genocide slaughter of Armenian Christians, Jews and other “infidels” by Muslim Turks which was simultaneous with the Gallipoli battle

Is this movie unfairly pro-Muslim? Is Islam depicted in a more favorable light than it deserves?

love of family

optimism / faith and hope

Copyright, Warner Bros. Pictures

SUICIDE—What does the Bible say? Answer

If a Christian commits suicide, will they go to Heaven? Answer

being angry at God

Did God make the world the way it is now? What kind of world would you create? Answer

Why does God allow innocent people to suffer? Answer

What about the issue of suffering? Doesn’t this prove that there is no God and that we are on our own? Answer

Does God feel our pain? Answer

ORIGIN OF BAD—How did bad things come about? Answer

dangers of relying on feelings instead of truth and reason

dowsing / water diviners / divination

What is the Occult? Answer

THE OCCULT—What does the Bible say about it? Answer

Can mysticism lead to God?

Featuring Russell CroweJoshua Connor
Olga KurylenkoAyshe
Isabel LucasNatalia
Jai Courtney … Lt-Col Cyril Hughes
Damon Herriman … Father McIntyre
Jacqueline McKenzie … Eliza, Joshua Connor’s wife
Ryan Corr … Art
Cem Yilmaz … Cemal
Megan Gale … Fatma
Deniz Akdeniz … Imam
Yilmaz Erdogan … Major Hasan
See all »
Director Russell Crowe
Producer Fear of God Films
Hopscotch Features
See all »
Distributor: Warner Brothers Pictures. Trademark logo.
Warner Bros. Pictures
, a Warner Bros. Entertainment Company

Russell Crowe’s directorial debut is beautiful to look at, features some characters you care about, and it contains exciting battle and chase sequences. Yet, I found the film unbelievable in too many of its plot points, so the film ultimately felt manipulative and contrived.

Joshua Connor (Russell Crowe) has lost his entire family because of the battle at Gallipoli during WWI, which claimed tens of thousands of lives. His mission in the film is to journey from Australia to Turkey and locate the remains of his three young sons amidst the bones of thousands buried there four years before.

Because he seemingly has the ability to use sticks to determine where to dig and find water, he also seems to have enough clairvoyance to figure out the exact spot where his sons died agonizing deaths, which we view via flashback. Watching these young men suffer will live on in my memory as one of the most horrible depictions of war since Oliver Stone’s “Platoon.”

Mr. Connor moves from one lucky encounter to another, as he constantly receives the precise information he needs from minor characters to lead him toward his goal of bringing his sons home to be buried. Most plots have elements of chance in them that can move a story forward, but this movie asks us to accept that its lead character is either the luckiest man on Earth or is being led toward his destiny by visions, magnetic pulses, or other phenomena to achieve all his goals. After too many coincidences, this story, hinging upon the reality of a terrible war, becomes lost in a strange mysticism where, for instance, the pattern of coffee grounds determine whom you will marry.

If you go see “The Water Diviner,” you might have a good cry, seeing a father’s love for his sons and feeling the pain of their loss, but the movie doesn’t end up earning those tears.

If you go see the film, despite my schmaltz warning, you can expect to see plenty of people killing one another brutally in war, hear a little profanity, watch a wicked priest weasel money from a grieving man, see some buttocks as men swim at a beach, observe some prostitutes at work, and see a couple of suicides (essentially).

One might describe some of the most brutal scenes as “gut-wrenching.” In the early 1980s, Australian director Peter Weir made “Gallipoli” (1981), starring Mel Gibson, which dealt with this ferocious battle in a much more moving, realistic way that didn’t need tons of blood and guts to make you feel empathy for the plight of those doomed soldiers. I highly recommend that film over “The Water Diviner,” which wastes some good acting by mixing too much fantasy with historical facts to strange effect.

Violence: Heavy to extreme / Profanity: Moderate—“My G*d” (1), “Oh G*d” (1), “damn” (30), “hell” (2), “a**” (1), “a**-hole” (1), s-word (1), “slut,” “bloody,” “b*gger,” “b*stards” / Sex/Nudity: Moderate

Editor’s Note: According to a Wikipedia article, “The movie drew criticism in the U.S. as it was released on the 100 year anniversary of the Armenian Genocide while the film itself failed to mention the genocide at all. Salon accused the film of historical white-washing. TheWrap published an op-ed from directors Garin Hovannisian and Alec Mouhibian who called the movie ‘the the highest profile piece of propaganda ever produced in the service of genocide denial’.” Movieguide called the film “Pro-Muslim, Pro-Turkish, Occult Romanticism… Patriotic Australians and Armenian Christians should deplore this movie, which is fatally and morally, spiritually and artistically flawed. Muslims in Turkey probably will love it, however.”

See list of Relevant Issues—questions-and-answers.

Viewer CommentsSend your comments
Positive—“Water Diviner” is an important movie from the perspective of Australian culture. It is the first movie to directly address the ANZAC tradition primarily in terms of reconciliation and forgiveness. This also makes it an important movie from the Christian perspective. The omission of any sex scenes, and avoiding the use of “Jesus” and “Christ” as swear words, place this in the better than average category for me.

The nudity is so brief and so distant as to be hardly worth consideration. The battle violence is confronting, and so I would recommend this movie only for mature teenagers and older. What could be called “battle field euthanasia” is an aspect of war that is very rarely addressed, and one is left to decide whether this can ever be justified.

Some Christians might object to the practice of water divining (trying to find sources of underground water by holding metal rods or wooden sticks) as a form of sorcery. Personally, I think it has a scientific basis (supported by research by physicist Dr. Larry Marshall) and remember the valuable well found on our farm by a water diviner. Connor locating the site of his sons’ remains by a “sixth sense” may also be problematic for some Christians, but I think many of us parents have experienced knowing something about our children not immediately apparent to our senses, so I was not too disturbed by this.

I was disappointed that the only representative of the Church in this movie is a harsh and hypocritical clergyman. On the other hand, a mosque is depicted as a place of reverence and worship.
My Ratings: Moral rating: Better than Average / Moviemaking quality: 4
Ken, age 69 (Australia)
Comments from young people
Neutral—First of all, I will list all that I admire about the movie. The profanity is very light compared to what is in most movies nowadays. You will not hear a single F-bomb or GD, although there are few minor cuss words.

There are no sexual scenes, not so much as a small kiss between Joshua and the female protagonist. There was a single scene where a woman, although fully dressed, was shown exiting a bathroom before or after (I can’t remember exactly) a man. She then crossed the hall and halfway went into another room, presumably hers. Before fully entering however, she turned around and looked at Joshua (who was sitting on a bench waiting for his turn to use the bathroom) and said something along the lines of “come back later,” although I cannot remember exact words. Nothing more was shown. and if you are anything like my mother, it may well fly over your head. See all »
My Ratings: Moral rating: Average / Moviemaking quality: 5
Em, age 15 (USA)
Movie Critics
…emotionally manipulative…
Eddie Cockrell, Variety
…earnest bombast… bogged down in a plot that seems to have no end… [2/5]
Marc Savlov, The Austin Chronicle
…The awfulness and futility of war are seared onto the screen, in images that are often hard to look at. … [2½/4]
Peter Howell, Toronto Star Newspapers
…a mournful and skeptical antiwar picture …The film's fuzzy mystical undertones are irksome… The film's sense of history and politics is a muddle as well. … [2/4]
Matt Zoller Seitz,
…historians aghast at The Water Diviner’s pro-Turkish slant… [2/4]
Brad Wheeler, The Globe and Mail
…You don’t have to be a historian to wonder about the timing of the opening or a critic to regret that Mr. Crowe has signed onto a preposterous, would-be sweeping historical romance that’s far too slight and silly to carry the weight of real history. …
Manohla Dargis, The New York Times
…It’s less a moving story than a story that knows how to look like a moving story. …There’s just enough of a high-gloss historical sheen that you couldn’t make the charges of vanity project stick, but Russell Crowe the director sure does find an awful lot of upstanding, stirring and utterly manly things for Russell Crowe the actor to do in The Water Diviner. …[2/4]
David Berry, National Post
…There’s little subtlety or nuance in The Water Diviner. …[2½/4]
Steven Rea, Philadelphia Inquirer

PLEASE share your observations and insights to be posted here.